DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Hamza Yusuf and Fons Vitae (Perennialist Publishing company)

**aaafluochugh** · 09-04-2012, 02:57 AM

salaam br.

wow a takfir on an ahlus sunnah scholar!

have you read up on shaykh hamzas side of the story before you did so br?

shaykh hamza is far more learned and intelligent than the general scholars from the indian subcontinent in my view so to issue takfir on him based on a fatwa from alamah 'kashmiri' is to be a bit hasty i'd say br.

go into that perrenialism is kufr thread again and read up the posts on how takfir is not issued on 'taweel' even if the opinion is apperant kufr; haamza yusuf bases his 'tollerance' of perrenialism on that but even he says it falls into the catogory of a foul bidah

Walaikum as sallam.

I have not done any specific Takfir on anyone and nor am i entitled to do so. I have just shared what Imam Anwar Shah Kashmiri rahimahullah has said. It is an emotional trick from the "traditional modernist camp" to accuse anyone of being a "takfeeri" who disagrees with them.Secondly,i don't think so that Hamza belongs to Ahle Sunnah wal jamaat after his comments about the Lahori Qadyanis.

09-04-2012, 02:57 AM	#21
aaafluochugh Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 473 Senior Member	salaam br. wow a takfir on an ahlus sunnah scholar! have you read up on shaykh hamzas side of the story before you did so br? shaykh hamza is far more learned and intelligent than the general scholars from the indian subcontinent in my view so to issue takfir on him based on a fatwa from alamah 'kashmiri' is to be a bit hasty i'd say br. go into that perrenialism is kufr thread again and read up the posts on how takfir is not issued on 'taweel' even if the opinion is apperant kufr; haamza yusuf bases his 'tollerance' of perrenialism on that but even he says it falls into the catogory of a foul bidah Walaikum as sallam. I have not done any specific Takfir on anyone and nor am i entitled to do so. I have just shared what Imam Anwar Shah Kashmiri rahimahullah has said. It is an emotional trick from the "traditional modernist camp" to accuse anyone of being a "takfeeri" who disagrees with them.Secondly,i don't think so that Hamza belongs to Ahle Sunnah wal jamaat after his comments about the Lahori Qadyanis.
	Quote