DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Hamza Yusuf and Fons Vitae (Perennialist Publishing company)

**Switiespils** · 09-04-2012, 02:57 AM

, that they shouldnt as he could have changed his extremely contreversial views later on in his life

Fatwa is issued on the Dhahir of a person without looking into his Batin. There is a narration in Sahih Bukhari which says that Umar Ibn al Khatab radhiallahu anhu once said to a person that the divine has been suspended and we shall just see your outwardly action and deal you according to that no matter what you claim about your Batin as Batin is only known to Allah.

So if a person has done some act of Kufar , a fatwa is issued against him without considering his intentions and later on repentance ( If there is no proof that he has repented later). So if he has repented , Allah is not going to throw him into hell due to that Fatwa issued against him nor is Allah going to punish the one who issued the Fatwa as he remained unaware of his repentance. Such "he may have repented" theory can be considered for each and every human being and the favor should be extended to Ghulam Qadyani as well as he might have repented as well.

09-04-2012, 02:57 AM	#27
Switiespils Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 619 Senior Member	, that they shouldnt as he could have changed his extremely contreversial views later on in his life Fatwa is issued on the Dhahir of a person without looking into his Batin. There is a narration in Sahih Bukhari which says that Umar Ibn al Khatab radhiallahu anhu once said to a person that the divine has been suspended and we shall just see your outwardly action and deal you according to that no matter what you claim about your Batin as Batin is only known to Allah. So if a person has done some act of Kufar , a fatwa is issued against him without considering his intentions and later on repentance ( If there is no proof that he has repented later). So if he has repented , Allah is not going to throw him into hell due to that Fatwa issued against him nor is Allah going to punish the one who issued the Fatwa as he remained unaware of his repentance. Such "he may have repented" theory can be considered for each and every human being and the favor should be extended to Ghulam Qadyani as well as he might have repented as well.
	Quote