DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Hamza Yusuf and Fons Vitae (Perennialist Publishing company)

**ttiokjbnhjjillp** · 09-04-2012, 02:57 AM

With due respect to Shaykh Hamza Yusuf, who no doubt is a seeker of ilm, but as he said in his own words close to the effect no one has a monopoly over truth, i shall remind the same to his blind followers that Shaykh Hamza with all his scholarly abilities , doesnt hold a monopoly over truth, so yes he can make mistakes, and not just once, get ready to accept he can make a number of mistakes.

Also in his own words, close to the meaning, he recommeneded his students to never follow completely one person after Prophet S.W, so advise to his students, dont blind follow, keep an open mind, learn from all the scholors, be it the giants from sub-continent, with their unmatched scholorship in this deen, be it from the blessed arab lands, be it from the west.This way you will protect yourself from falling into the errors of those scholors whose words you take as wahi.

Get over with personality worship, your shaykh is just another shaykh in the rows of thousands of mashaikh, and if your shaykh/teachers has gone againsts the majority of mashaikh, then accept that, and do not arrogantly claim that he is far intelligent than the others, because intelligence anyways gives nuthing, it is only Taqwa of a scholor which brings him acceptability in the eyes of Allah.

Accept that it is a fact Shaykh Hamza has gone against the majority of the scholors in this Masla of Lahori Qadiyanis.

09-04-2012, 02:57 AM	#35
ttiokjbnhjjillp Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 436 Senior Member	With due respect to Shaykh Hamza Yusuf, who no doubt is a seeker of ilm, but as he said in his own words close to the effect no one has a monopoly over truth, i shall remind the same to his blind followers that Shaykh Hamza with all his scholarly abilities , doesnt hold a monopoly over truth, so yes he can make mistakes, and not just once, get ready to accept he can make a number of mistakes. Also in his own words, close to the meaning, he recommeneded his students to never follow completely one person after Prophet S.W, so advise to his students, dont blind follow, keep an open mind, learn from all the scholors, be it the giants from sub-continent, with their unmatched scholorship in this deen, be it from the blessed arab lands, be it from the west.This way you will protect yourself from falling into the errors of those scholors whose words you take as wahi. Get over with personality worship, your shaykh is just another shaykh in the rows of thousands of mashaikh, and if your shaykh/teachers has gone againsts the majority of mashaikh, then accept that, and do not arrogantly claim that he is far intelligent than the others, because intelligence anyways gives nuthing, it is only Taqwa of a scholor which brings him acceptability in the eyes of Allah. Accept that it is a fact Shaykh Hamza has gone against the majority of the scholors in this Masla of Lahori Qadiyanis.
	Quote