DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**shiciapsisy** · 09-04-2012, 02:56 AM

.

Thank you for your answers....May be the article i was reading was a bit biased on the ashari's part....

However i did read something on that article that i didn't know before and that was regarding the difference of opinion on predestination between the ashari and maturdi..? For example Maturdi emphasized on free will a bit More and Linked predestination to Foreknowledge of Allah to a greater detail..I don't know how to put it ...Just that > we do what we do Not because its determined BUT Allah knows about it..Any one can shed some light on it.?? And my belief is Anything that happens is by the will of Allah and it doesn't happen with out it.And the accountability is there because we don't FEEL THE FORCE.(acquiring an action)..?Any idea Regarding this would be helpful.
Thank you

brother read this thread you will find it interesting.

http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/show...-Aqeedah/page4

what is your aqeedah?

I have to say brother that personally I try to limit my personal views on this to the Athari view and what is contained within the creed of Malik and the Tahawiyya

I am not against the Asharis or Maturidis, nor am I saying that they are wrong per say, Indeed most of the later great Imams of the religion were Ashari or Maturidi in Aqeedah,

but the athari view is safer (even Ashari/Maturidi scholars have agreed this) whereas the Ashari and Maturidi views involve human thoughts over which there may be doubts.

09-04-2012, 02:56 AM	#6
shiciapsisy Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 485 Senior Member	. Thank you for your answers....May be the article i was reading was a bit biased on the ashari's part.... However i did read something on that article that i didn't know before and that was regarding the difference of opinion on predestination between the ashari and maturdi..? For example Maturdi emphasized on free will a bit More and Linked predestination to Foreknowledge of Allah to a greater detail..I don't know how to put it ...Just that > we do what we do Not because its determined BUT Allah knows about it..Any one can shed some light on it.?? And my belief is Anything that happens is by the will of Allah and it doesn't happen with out it.And the accountability is there because we don't FEEL THE FORCE.(acquiring an action)..?Any idea Regarding this would be helpful. Thank you brother read this thread you will find it interesting. http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/show...-Aqeedah/page4 what is your aqeedah? I have to say brother that personally I try to limit my personal views on this to the Athari view and what is contained within the creed of Malik and the Tahawiyya I am not against the Asharis or Maturidis, nor am I saying that they are wrong per say, Indeed most of the later great Imams of the religion were Ashari or Maturidi in Aqeedah, but the athari view is safer (even Ashari/Maturidi scholars have agreed this) whereas the Ashari and Maturidi views involve human thoughts over which there may be doubts.
	Quote