DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Is it true that timetables say that subh sadiq ends early?

**Kimmitmelvirm** · 09-21-2012, 04:14 PM

I don't think the brother is trying to be controversial in any way. I think you have misunderstood his intentions. There is only one mosque in my locality and it follows the 15 degrees ruling, hence there are some of us in the dilemma as to whether to inform others, who are ignorant of the matter, that this is not an "viable" opinion (inevitably this will cause some kinda of commotion by the community). However if the 15 degrees ruling is a viable opinion then why the need to cause commotion.

I am not aware of any masjid in the UK that follows 15 degrees

They either follow 18 degrees or the research of a small group ( 3-4 ) hizbul ulama in which their times fluctuates from lower than 12 degrees to over 18 degrees

Let's leave out the argument of either 18 or 15 degrees and purely concentrate on the mushahada of hizbul ulama research, then we will understand that it is not permissible to follow their research

Then the question would be what do the people of UK do ?

The answer was given to the ulama of UK by mufti mahmood ul hassan gangohi and that was to use the 18 degrees method

09-21-2012, 04:14 PM	#24
Kimmitmelvirm Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 416 Senior Member	I don't think the brother is trying to be controversial in any way. I think you have misunderstood his intentions. There is only one mosque in my locality and it follows the 15 degrees ruling, hence there are some of us in the dilemma as to whether to inform others, who are ignorant of the matter, that this is not an "viable" opinion (inevitably this will cause some kinda of commotion by the community). However if the 15 degrees ruling is a viable opinion then why the need to cause commotion. I am not aware of any masjid in the UK that follows 15 degrees They either follow 18 degrees or the research of a small group ( 3-4 ) hizbul ulama in which their times fluctuates from lower than 12 degrees to over 18 degrees Let's leave out the argument of either 18 or 15 degrees and purely concentrate on the mushahada of hizbul ulama research, then we will understand that it is not permissible to follow their research Then the question would be what do the people of UK do ? The answer was given to the ulama of UK by mufti mahmood ul hassan gangohi and that was to use the 18 degrees method
	Quote