DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Was the author of al-Hidayah fee an-nahw sunni or shi'a?

**Yyaqyped** · 07-30-2012, 06:20 AM

السلام عليكم

Look I said it wasn't worth looking into and this is true, but since I had some time on my hands I looked into it myself very quickly.

This is the fifth print by the Shia, as you can see it is intended to be taught in their Hawzat, and they said they edited some unclear phrases in it.

In their print you can read "`Aliyyan (as) Imama" at the bottom.

But then I went and got my hands on the manuscript.

And as you can read in the manuscript, the bottom of page 61 on the right, there is no mention of `Ali (ra), it says Zaid instead.

And Allah knows best.

07-30-2012, 06:20 AM	#9
Yyaqyped Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 469 Senior Member	السلام عليكم Look I said it wasn't worth looking into and this is true, but since I had some time on my hands I looked into it myself very quickly. This is the fifth print by the Shia, as you can see it is intended to be taught in their Hawzat, and they said they edited some unclear phrases in it. In their print you can read "`Aliyyan (as) Imama" at the bottom. But then I went and got my hands on the manuscript. And as you can read in the manuscript, the bottom of page 61 on the right, there is no mention of `Ali (ra), it says Zaid instead. And Allah knows best.
	Quote