As i said cadburyboy thats his opinion..its not HJ Bashing or anything...its more of a review than a provoking comment...i guess ur hastened too much...relax http://www.discussworldissues.com/fo...on_biggrin.gif

ok then!!!

YES !!! YSR 100 TIMES BETTER THAN HJ 4 ME.PRUTI VEERAN SIMLY ROCKS http://www.discussworldissues.com/fo...s/thumbsup.gif

HJ has learnt everything from ARR except .... but to compare him with YSR he needs minimum 6 months exclusive training from IR for bgms. That will basically help him how to compose a tune first. http://www.discussworldissues.com/fo...on_biggrin.gif

On any given day, I will pick Mani Sharma over these 2 guys......

It is unfortunate an industry that produced masters like IR and ARR has to choose between 2 loosers...

நேற்றுதான் பச்சை கிளி முத்துச்சரம் பாடல்களை கேட்டேன். எப்படிதான் ஹரிஷினால் இப்படி Play Smart பண்ண முடியுதுனு தெரியில.. இவரோட பாடல்களில் இவரது புத்திசாலித்தனம்தான் தெரியுது. இசையோட நலினம் தெரியில... He is a Pure Commercial Music Director... காதல் கொஞ்சம் பாடலில் அப்படியே நியூ யோர்க் நகரம் சாயல்..அதே chords பயன்படுத்தி வேறு மாதிரியான பாடலை உருவாக்கி தனது புத்திசாலித்தனத்தை நிருபித்திருக்கிறார். ஹரிஸ் அவர்களே...எங்களுக்கு வேண்டியது உங்களின் புத்திசாலித்தனம் அல்ல...உங்களின் புதிய இசை பரிணாமம். மின்னலே, சமுராய், 12B போன்ற படங்களில் அது தெரிந்தது. இன்னும் நான் 'மூங்கில் காடுகளே'க்கு அடிமை. தயவு செஞ்சு கொஞ்சம் மாறுங்க சார்.

>>also, he has this advantage of being Raaja's son which puts half of Tamilnadu in his pocket.....thats a head start he has on HJ who has just neutral guys for his support.........

maddy if u say this for yuvan, then harris too had the advantage of coming from ARR's camp which had put half of tamilnadu's youth into his pocket in his initial days..... (as far as i know atleast till Saami days and to a certain extent even now)....okie as for the opportunities he got, accepted, it is hard work http://www.discussworldissues.com/fo...icon_smile.gif

kadhal kondein,7g,pudhupetai,mounam paesiyadhe,manmadhan just for bgms they stand way ahead of any harris's copies of arr

samy,kaaka kaaka,12b,minnale iruntha harris music 'alai'or[crazy]ippa konjam kuranja mathiri thonuthu http://www.discussworldissues.com/fo...n_rolleyes.gif

he is pure commercial md-yes,athala santhegame illai.100% true.itha sonna than 'oru silarukku kovam pottu kittu varuthe sir http://www.discussworldissues.com/fo...lies/ymlol.gif

http://www.discussworldissues.com/fo...on_biggrin.gif http://www.discussworldissues.com/fo...on_biggrin.gif aana enna mayomoh manthiramo theriyila....HJ podura pattu mattum hit avuthu.....makkalukkum theriyuthu avaru thiruppi thiruppi repeat pandrarunu...appavum athai vangurangale...aanaa orutharu kasthappattu thailand philharmonic musician lam vaichu vellaikaran mari soundtrack potta kuuda....yaarum kandukka matturanga... http://www.discussworldissues.com/fo...lies/ymlol.gif http://www.discussworldissues.com/fo...lies/ymlol.gif enna ulagamo pongappa......

sari..sari!!!mr.sehnthan,ithukellam 'oppari'vechaa enna garathu http://www.discussworldissues.com/fo...n_rolleyes.gif ennakku ennamo tamilanukku 'sweet'inna romba pidikkum,anthanala hj songs romba pidikkutho ennavo http://www.discussworldissues.com/fo.../confused2.gif hj songs'la romba sweet athigam.anaa sweet than body'kku romba trabule!!! http://www.discussworldissues.com/fo...lies/ymlol.gif http://www.discussworldissues.com/fo...lies/ymlol.gif

samy,kaaka kaaka,12b,minnale iruntha harris music 'alai'or[crazy]ippa konjam kuranja mathiri thonuthu http://www.discussworldissues.com/fo...n_rolleyes.gif Its the other way round, Anand. The craze is more among high school and college goers (atleast from my experience in Singapore) Till the class starts, they listen to HJ songs more, in lunch-breaks, speak about the orchestra etc. and play in keyboards and in big chorus. They constantly write to him, even managed to meet up with him (when he was at Singapore for Bheema composition) with the help of another fanclub member. No we here only UU songs everywhere.. be it class or outside.

samy,kaaka kaaka,12b,minnale iruntha harris music 'alai'or[crazy]ippa konjam kuranja mathiri thonuthu http://www.discussworldissues.com/fo...n_rolleyes.gif Its the other way round, Anand. The craze is more among high school and college goers (atleast from my experience in Singapore) Till the class starts, they listen to HJ songs more, in lunch-breaks, speak about the orchestra etc. and play in keyboards and in big chorus. They constantly write to him, even managed to meet up with him (when he was at Singapore for Bheema composition) with the help of another fanclub member. No we here only UU songs everywhere.. be it class or outside. ithala ellam peruma pada enna irkku??

perumaikkaga illai.. ullathai (nadakkirathai) sonnen..

experimentation, innovation, content ithai ellam vida mukkiamaanathu ennathunna presentation than where HJ scores over YSR.

BTW, last weekend i went to my native place where i listened Deepavali songs in outside places.

Its the other way round, Anand. The craze is more among high school and college goers (atleast from my experience in Singapore) Till the class starts, they listen to HJ songs more, in lunch-breaks, speak about the orchestra etc. and play in keyboards and in big chorus. They constantly write to him, even managed to meet up with him (when he was at Singapore for Bheema composition) with the help of another fanclub member. No we here only UU songs everywhere.. be it class or outside. bhuvana
this may be the case in singapore but in tamilnadu esp chennai yuvan has a better fanfare esp among youth coll and high school goers.no music directors except IR and ARR gets whistles and claps in theatres whe their name gets displayed in the title.but its just amazing yuvan is the nxt only guy to get whistles when his name gets displyed during the title of the movie.
commercial success beckons yuvan simply bcos he goes on for films of debutant heroes,directors etc mostly yet to compose for any biggies,lack of proper marketing or promoting,too much experimentation and scores too many movies in a year.but its the other way around for harris.he tastes sucess evn before the movie release.
take for instance VV first thing its a kaml starrer ,then the hype the film had even before the release.anotheer example is 'pachaikili muthucharam"alomost everyday this trailer comes between any programme.so obviously the more u hear u start to hum that song.another thing about harris movie is he doesn go for folk songs or dapankuthu songs.obviously he doesn get films demanding that but still that is one of the reason y gilrls love his songs.basicsally girls don like dapankuthu songs.recent times yuvan was given more folk and dapankuthu related movies .
the point is yuvan has more fans than harris but still fail commercially cos of the above reasonshttp://www.discussworldissues.com/fo...milies/huh.gif

i totally agree with kartik

i cant belive that why didnt you guys understand the difference between a movie being commercial hit and a movie being musical hit.Most of Harris jayaraj movies are comercially big hits but not all of them are musical hits, but half of Yuvans movies did badly at BO but musical hits.

Whenever HJ worked with big shots like Goutham, Shankar and Murugadaas the songs became big hits, this would happen regardless of any MD's.Even Anniyan and Saamy songs didnt received well by fans initially , once the movie became big hit, the songs were also started to do well.On the other hand even though the songs of the movie Leysa Leysa are really good (only one of my HJ favourite other than Minnale) but it wasnt a musical when compared with HJ's other hit, 'cos movie is not commercial hit.

But when you look at the movies he did with not so big shots like Hari and others (Kovil, Majnu,Arul, Arashatchi,samurai etc) he failed miserably musicwise and movies were also flops.this is where Yuvan score better than HJ , even though almost all of his movies are not with bigshots (apart from Vasanth and lingusamy i guess) but 80% of them are musical hits.

The bottom line is in 2004 and 2005 Yuvan gave commercial hits like manmathan, raam, AA and pattiyal back to back so he was hyped by media as No 1 MD and so and so. but in 2005 and 2006 HJ gave big hits like Gajini and VV back to back so he has been celebrated by media , cinema people and fans right now.But when you compare Yuvan and HJ in Quality, innovation, trend setting music, BGM Youvan scores over HJ comportably.

well said,NG