[pavilionnotebook]

If you want to compare stats and stats alone, then you would take Peyton.

But he has played 8 to 10 games per year indoors. No wind, no rain, no receivers slipping, receivers always making sharp cuts. No plays ever being affected by the elements. I would think he gets a few points added to his completion % every year

Speaking of recievers; Have the Giants had any WR better than Marvin Harrison or Reggie Wayne? Have they had a TE better than Dallas Clark? have they had a RB better than Edgerin James?

He also had the same OC for his entire career until 2010.

2010 was also his worst passer rating since 2001.