[avaincmolla]

And I know it's been said, but how in the hell did they review that as an actual catch?

[Alexeric]

McGahee is a man! How convenient that they only flag the Broncos on that.

[UHlVExs7]

There really wasn't much evidence to overturn it. The ball never moved after he hit the ground. You would have to make assumptions of thing you could not see to overturn it.

The ball dragged along the ground half the catch. The ground was the reason he held onto it.

[avaincmolla]

Were Patriots' fans booing Carter because he's injured?

[Alexeric]

Were Patriots' fans booing Carter because he's injured?

Yes.

[Tainlyferfara]

The ball dragged along the ground half the catch. The ground was the reason he held onto it.

You are assuming it did, there was no video of it. He never regripped the ball at all during or after the slide his hand never moved and he had control when he came up still never regripped so there was no visual evidence he lost control. It's a grey area that could have been called either way but to call it incomplete you would have to make assumptions as there was not visual evidence that he lost control of the ball.

[Alexeric]

His hands were on the sides of the ball and the point of the ball was dragged along the ground.

[avaincmolla]

Vince McMahon runs the NFL.

[Alexeric]

Vince McMahon runs the NFL.

Clearly. The definition of a catch changes week to week.

[UHlVExs7]

There was tons of visual evidence. They had the best possible camera angles you could get...lol

[Tainlyferfara]

His hands were on the sides of the ball and the point of the ball was dragged along the ground.

You need to look at it again, his one hand was around the middle of the ball and he had it pinned to his chest. The bottom of the ball probably did hit the ground but there is no video of it and he never juggled it, he had control of it all the way through, they shouldn't overturn things based on assumptions.

[avaincmolla]

You need to look at it again, his one hand was around the middle of the ball and he had it pinned to his chest. The bottom of the ball probably did hit the ground but there is no video of it and he never juggled it, he had control of it all the way through, they shouldn't overturn things based on assumptions.

To quote George Costanza, "It moved."

[Tainlyferfara]

There was tons of visual evidence. They had the best possible camera angles you could get...lol

Wrong, you could see the top of the ball and his hand and his body. You never saw the ball hit the ground, which it did...which it is allowed to do but he never moved his hand once he hit the ground. Had he moved his hand I think they make it incomplete.

[UHlVExs7]

You're outnumbered man. We all say it was a drop, and the announcers said it would be overturned based on what we all saw. It moved around a lot.

[Tainlyferfara]

You're outnumbered man. We all say it was a drop, and the announcers said it would be overturned based on what we all saw. It moved around a lot.

You are in Jim nantz and Phil Simms company, idiots. It's my opinion, if you go back and look at his right hand he never juggles the ball, never moves his right hand from the time he hit the ground and even after he got back up giving the officials no reason to believe he ever losts control.

[UHlVExs7]

He never HAD control

[avaincmolla]

Why don't the Broncos have receivers running routes on these option plays?

[Tainlyferfara]

He never HAD control

I'll agree that we disagree.

[avaincmolla]

This game sucks.

[Alexeric]

Ballgame