[Fluivelip]

If Montana had the rule book Manning gets to work with(no hitting the qb, wr cushions, ect), the 49ers would have won 8 Super Bowls. When you get a chance, look up how many Super Bowl INTs Montana threw in four games, and get back to me.

[KinicsBonee]

as much as i hate favre anybody that doesn't have him in their top five is full of shit

In my top 10, not top 5.

[KeettyGlots]

Oh. This is supposed to be a biased list?

1. Mcnabb
2. Cunningham
3. Jaworski

Yep, 1 out of 10 picks means the whole list is biased.

[sesWaipunsaws]

as much as i hate favre anybody that doesn't have him in their top five is full of shit

why?

[Faigokilix]

Simms only made 2 pro bowls. That's pretty shocking to me, I remember him as one of the better quarterbacks of the 80s

[Aswdwdfg]

Phil Simms guid', Phil Simms.

Shouldn't a top 5 QB be, you know, in the top 20 in some sort of statistic, other than taking sacks?

[u8MmZFmF]

Phil Simms was *maybe* one of the top 5 QB's of his generation. 6th all time?? You done bumped your head son.


1.) Otto Graham.
2.) Bart Starr
3a.) Dan Marino
3b.) Joe Montana
5a.) Brett Favre
5b.) Peyton Manning

Elway, Young, Unitas just missed the cut.

[ThzinChang]

In my top 10, not top 5.

i wouldn't even put him in my top 10.

[sonsayx]

i wouldn't even put him in my top 10.

He is in there for that streak alone probably.

[squeerisott]

as much as i hate favre anybody that doesn't have him in their top five is full of shit

Well, my eyes are brown anyways. {shrugs}

[adactthrd]

5. Simms (yeah I said it)

Ernie Simms plays linebacker.

HA!

..

[Affiltavajefe]

He is in there for that streak alone probably.

that's ridiculous. how many times did he play with that bum thumb and fuck his team over because he couldn't hold on to the ball or throw it properly?

[lapyignipinge]

Shouldn't a top 5 QB be, you know, in the top 20 in some sort of statistic, other than taking sacks?

Maybe. But what did he mean to the NYG? Where were NYG if we had Jeff or Dave running the offense?

[JasminBerkova]

1. Dan Marino
2. Joe Montana
3. Terry Bradshaw
4. Tom Brady
5. John Elway

Everybody else has can sign up to attempt to wash these guys cleats.

[goolen4you]

that's ridiculous. how many times did he play with that bum thumb and fuck his team over because he couldn't hold on to the ball or throw it properly?

he and reggie white put GB back on the map.

[lionsiy]

1. Dan Marino
2. Joe Montana
3. Terry Bradshaw
4. Tom Brady
5. John Elway

Everybody else has can sign up to attempt to wash these guys cleats.

A Bradshaw sighting, impressive.

[@Aerodyno@]

Maybe. But what did he mean to the NYG? Where were NYG if we had Jeff or Dave running the offense?

The Giants beat the Bills with Hostetler at QB. I'd say they would have been OK.

[sleelverrex]

The Giants beat the Bills with Hostetler at QB. I'd say they would have been OK.

Eh, I'm not so sure they would've. Maybe I am biased, but it's not like I tried to claim Jared Lorenzen was top 10 all-time.

[bunkalapa]

I think Peyton has the chance to be the best ever, but right now?

Montana, hands down.

4-0 in the Superbowl, 3 SB MVPs, and an astounding 11-0 TD/INT ratio in the big game.

He not only played and won 4 Superbowls, but he EXCELLED in them.

Besides that, Peyton is 3-8 in the playoffs EXCEPT for 2006 (4-0), and this year (2-0)

[strmini]

Eh, I'm not so sure they would've. Maybe I am biased, but it's not like I tried to claim Jared Lorenzen was top 10 all-time.

The hefty lefty.