[SashaLionx]

In a perfect world, they would look at each team, decide on 32 MVPs from each team, based on how much effect that persons play, has on their team. The player that has the greatest impact on thier team should be its MVP.

Then they should decide from those 32, who has the greatest impact of all. if you take that player out of the equation and does it really kill their team. Do some good hard analyise to determine which player is truely the MVP in the league.

Funny, Devin Hester becomes a solid canidate. Adrain Peterson, or even Steve Hutchison could be considered. But they doent look at it like that. Its really just a gut feeling call by the committee.

Its a good idea on the surface, but the fact is on a team of 53 players, finding just one guy isn't always the easiest thing to do. Perhaps you have a stud on both sides of the ball.

Likewise, if your team stinks but you're the "MVP" of your team, are you truly the 32nd most valuable guy in the entire league? I mean that guy on the worst team in the league might not even be a Pro Bowler.

[joanbertis]

Its a good idea on the surface, but the fact is on a team of 53 players, finding just one guy isn't always the easiest thing to do. Perhaps you have a stud on both sides of the ball.

Likewise, if your team stinks but you're the "MVP" of your team, are you truly the 32nd most valuable guy in the entire league? I mean that guy on the worst team in the league might not even be a Pro Bowler.

They already have an offensive and defensive MVP. There isn't a reason to not leave it that way if the adopted a format like this.

Also, there would likely be a number of guys in this format that receive no votes and in turn tying for last place in this thing. It really wouldn't be important as to who ended up in anything but first, so that really is a non-issue. This would end the current problem of teammates canceling eachother out. And if voters were honest in their vote this year, that SHOULD have actually come into play.

[Audi_z]

kerry collins is starting for a playoff team today, cunningham is hanging drywall.

well this is part of hte point, Kerry Collins is also a capable qb who Randy didn't make look like a world beater. Takes two to tango.

[LfYaRf1S]

Moss made Brady look this phenomenal. There's a reason why his career high in TDs was 28 before this season. If and when Moss leaves NE, Brady will go back to being a pretty good QB but not the best.

[NodePark]

well this is part of hte point, Kerry Collins is also a capable qb who Randy didn't make look like a world beater. Takes two to tango.

NE has an underrated OL. You give your QB some time and Moss can go and get any underthrown duck.

[Oppofeescom]

Moss made Brady look this phenomenal. There's a reason why his career high in TDs was 28 before this season. If and when Moss leaves NE, Brady will go back to being a pretty good QB but not the best.

exactly.

[Thunderzee]

well this is part of hte point, Kerry Collins is also a capable qb who Randy didn't make look like a world beater. Takes two to tango.

raiders are a shit team though. on ANY decent team, moss makes that qb golden.

[Fhgzmftq]

Kitna = the real MVP come on the lions won 7 games.

[WoCTrt0X]

Its probably the Journal Sentinal guy.

Nope. The sole vote for #4 was from . . .

...Frank Cooney, according to the Associated Press.

His vote kept the NFL MVP award from being unanimous for New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady, who got 49 of the 50 votes from a nationwide panel.

Cooney is the founder and publisher of the SportsXchange, an information provider for news organizations

[sasquatch999]

Nope. The sole vote for #4 was from . . .

...Frank Cooney, according to the Associated Press.

His vote kept the NFL MVP award from being unanimous for New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady, who got 49 of the 50 votes from a nationwide panel.

Cooney is the founder and publisher of the SportsXchange, an information provider for news organizations

Frank Cooney is the man!