[WeestDype]

I'd reword that from "athlete" to "football player" JayGlo. Noone can deny how good of an athlete he is, but as far as being a QB...he's overrated as hell

And I agree on that totally...he's got a lot to grasp before he's a good "QB".

And as far as Bonds goes, we're talking in the here & now...he's slowed a lot and he hasn't impressed me with his fielding...and like I said, his HRs are so fake...he should definately have an asterisk next to his total.

And like I said, his average is inflated because all the walks he gets gives him less at-bats.

I guarantee if this guy was actually pitched to and feared less, his numbers would go down so far...again, that's not even taking into account the "juice" factor.

[Giselle]

I don't know how many of you watched the KC-Atl game, but if you did you would realize that Vick isn't vastly overrated. The guy has the worst offensive line in football. He had guys on him all day long. One time, on play-action, he got hit before he could turn around to look down field. The guy is learning a new offensive system, and has crap for wide receivers. Once KC rolled through Atlanta's D several times, the Falcons were forced to throw, and with the horrible receiving corps of the Falcons, the D could come at him hard all day. He has work to do, but he's better than most of you seem to think.

[orerviche]

It's cool... Neil O Donnell is the guy he replaced.

Aand wasn't that after ODonnell won a super bowl with....the Giants?

[Ruiptuptubre]

Again, that's what I always thought about Stewart, who came up as a RB

Kordells been a Qb since college @ Colorado. Ask michigan about his hail mary exploits with Michael Westbrook. He did get a little time at wr on trick plays with pitt early in his career though.

[tactWeiccaf]

How can you call Jeter overrated when he's been a mighty big cog in the Yankees' World Series victories?

The greatest players show up when the pressure is at its highest and the spotlight is the brightest.

Gotta disagree with you on this one. And I hate the Yankees.

^^^^^^^^^^What he said!

[antiggill]

After another. . .*ahem*. . ."breathtaking" performance today, the question needs to be asked.

Yes...Derek Jeter

[Dildos]

You'd take Glenn?

WHY??

I just like Terry Glenn a lot more than Keyshawn. Keyshawn spends more time running his mouth than anything, and he rarely backs it up.

[dodsCooggipsehome]

Not sure if anyone said it but TIGER WOODS. The man is good at what he does, but everytime he is on tv the tv station pops a chub over him. He barely makes the cut and every shot of his is shown. like i said, I know he is good, but I think he is over rated.

[pXss8cyx]

if your talking kordell i agree he sucked as a QB

Kordell sucked period.

Sucky QB - Slash - Sucky RB - Slash Sucky WR

[Immarsecice]

i think vick should switch positions to running back

Again, that's what I always thought about Stewart, who came up as a RB

[22paseabelldaps]

i think vick should switch positions to running back

[Kokomoxcv]

I wouldn't bust my rear for a guy who disrupts every play with his desire to run, instead of being the QB.

If the criteria for overrating is being an NFL starter who gets the glitz without winning, then yes, he is overrated.

[gdjfhdf]

Ben Roethlisberger

[amagmasia]

You mean that he's overrated? If so, I'd have to disagree with you on that. Crumpler is as good as any hype he gets.

YOM: one of the best avatars EVER!

[BriKevin]

Michelle Wie


Greg Oden


Lebroom Shames


Emmitt Smith


Roy Jones Jr.

Brett Farve

[Poreponko]

Lebron cant possibly be overrated.

[Chito]

Lebron cant possibly be overrated.

When you're marked as the second coming of MJ before you actually win a NBA Finals game, you're overrated to me.

[AK47rulz]

When you're marked as the second coming of MJ before you actually win a NBA Finals game, you're overrated to me.

he is awesome though and if they can get a team together over there, hell definitely have a handful of rings.

[adunnyByday]

From what I can tell thus far, Adrian Peterson is overfuckingrated.

[PrettyFifa12]

Michael Vick is a grade A piece of shit in my book. Anyone who allows for, or takes part in dog fights deserves to be beaten mercilessly.