[FuXA8nQM]

tough to leave Jim Brown out of that mix

And Emmitt Smith and Curtis Martin, and Jerome Bettis, and Eric Dickerson, and Tony Dorsett, and Marcus allen and Franco Harris,
or Thurman Thomas
Marshall Faulk
Riggins
Simpson
Watters
George
Anderson
Dillon
Campbell
Taylor
Perry
Byner
Walker
Craig
Riggs
Csonka
McNeil
...

[Knqzjbmf]

It is one hard question to answer.

Unless your a bears fan.

Altho i look at it like 1A. and 1B. Neither was purely "better" than the other

[Oberjej]

I'll accept durable.

WTF. I will, too.

[everlastinge]

HE tainted the record and the NFL.

Simply because he decided to play till the end?

[Liabmeasez]

great ~ bad

north ~ south

beef ~ cheese

beer ~ beer

landry ~ lombardi

hot ~ cold

dallas ~ green bay

win ~ lose

love ~ hate

Yes.

Brett ~ Troy

Irvin ~ Sharpe (choo choo, baby. choo choo.)

Ice Bowl ~ Super Bowl

Bart ~ Don

Good ~ Evil

[adoreorerie]

Of course you didnt your a cowboys fan,if you were on the outside looking in,completely different image.

You guys have him confused with Irvin & Sanders.

[AmfitNom]

A flasher? I always saw him as a rather modest guy and not one to show the sausage.

Of course you didnt your a cowboys fan,if you were on the outside looking in,completely different image.

[Grapappytek]

It is one hard question to answer.

Yes it is. I don't even know who "How" is?

[iodillalm]

How was better?






Not sure if I could pick between them, but my vote goes for Sanders. He had no supporting cast.

This could be debated till the cows come home and HAS been here at SB...

Both men were freaking awesome and 2 of MY all time favorites to watch....

Top 2 RB's EVER in my eyes....

[mygalinasoo]

It's a tough call. Both great backs.

I thought Gale Sayers was the most amazingly talented running back I ever saw.

Good analysis fan. Gale was great.

[accelieda]

Hey leave America's favorite crackhead alone....lol ,and I'm not a Emmitt hater,just never really impressed me....if He would have been oh lets say reversed with Sanders.If Smith was a Lion and Sanders a Cowboy,would we even be discussing Smith at all?I dont think so.

Perhaps you should check out some games of the early 90s......too bad you elected to miss the games and the spectacular show of athleticism.

[Moupponge]

This could be debated till the cows come home and HAS been here at SB...

Both men were freaking awesome and 2 of MY all time favorites to watch....

Top 2 RB's EVER in my eyes....

It is one hard question to answer.

[Mister.levitra]

It's a losing battle on this board. It's not worth my time. Everybody should know my stance by now. Hating the Boys I can understand but refusing to give Emmitt the credit he deserves is failure to accept reality and recognize determined talent.

I liked Smith. I think he is 2nd all time IMO.

[Yyaqyped]

Certainly something you don't want to bang your cherished cheesehead hat up against. Trying that will simply make shredded cheese.

I don't own a cheesehead.

And, he couldn't tackle me, either.

[Alexeric]

Only 17 guys have over 10,ooo yards rushing.
Watters is #15 on the all-time rushing list between OJ and Eddie George.


http://www.pro-football-reference.com/misc/rsy.htm

I guess if you look at it that way. lol

[RorieSorNearop]

Simply because he decided to play till the end?

LOL...I'm just fucking with you.

I have nothing against Emmit. I just don't think he is one of the best backs ever. He was a product of that team. He played a long time. He is durable. I'll give him that much.

[BodoidearoLew]

Ricky Watters???????

Only 17 guys have over 10,ooo yards rushing.
Watters is #15 on the all-time rushing list between OJ and Eddie George.


http://www.pro-football-reference.com/misc/rsy.htm

[DoterForeva]

agreed, I hated the cowboys with a passion. how many frickin times in a row did the boys beat the Pack? I think it was 7 times at dallas before the schedule makers did us a favor put you guys in GB. that was a happy day.

Ill restate I think emmitt and acheman, were both class acts on and off the field. I still hate the coke head though.

Even hate the whole "Jacked Up!" segment on ESPN?

[mtautomoscow]

Good for you.


There are other kinds. But I won't ever go behind somebody's back to explain such.

...like SB gossip?

[mymnduccete]

Dj Dosier