| Reply to Thread New Thread |
10-23-2005, 08:00 AM
|
#1 |
|
|
Vishnus' next outing after SARVAM planned with AJITH.Atlast some real big movies for YSR.
|
|
|
10-30-2005, 07:00 AM
|
#2 |
|
|
hmmm...its funny u said there isnt any other Hit songs from Varalaaru and SOK.... ive been seeing Suntv playing Dhinam Deepavali,Kama Karayile, Innisai & Kaatril songs beeing played through out the day.....esp Kaatril....they played it very often in a day...
SOK....JIllunu oru kadhal,Machakari, Munbe Va,New York Nagaram..these were the hits in the album....ofcource, ive noticed they only play Machkari & Munbe Va.... and as u know,they cant play Jilunnu Oru Kadhal as it was used as the BGM for the credit,that too in a diff version... NEw York is played in local radio quite often enough to be called a fav among the massess.... Dirs def play a huge role in a MD's success,if not y do u think they alwiz mention about a combo between a dir & md ?? [ Selva & YSR, ARR & MR/Shankar, HJ & Gautham] ??they will be able to know ur capabilty and extract that hidden magic within u into a song... i notice this happened in many combo,without failing EVERYTIME... proof to me that any of the above mentioned combo ever failed?? about Anniyan, a pause button between ARR & Shankar, infact, a huge hit in the year 2005... that didint motivate Shankar to use HJ for Shivaji, knowing his 'home' is alwiz ARR.... Anniyan songs were nothing but compilation of previous ARR-Shankar songs, thats what actually that album moved into a huge hit in tamil.... with HJ songs beeing a huge hit nowdays,i would say its ARR style & music that is living !again & again....thanks to HJ!! again here im not saying HJ is nothing but ARR's clone, he has composed many good songs,and his songs r very catchy,but i think he needs more depth in his songs... seriously i feel Partha Mudhal naal lacks many many elements that a love song needs.... its a hit,yes,but seriously,something is missing.....i dunno wut.... and BACK TO THE ACTUALY TOPIC OF THE THREAD..... YSR on the other hand is not having any promising dirs in hand except Selva...his non-selva songs r beeing repetitive & jaring.... there is where he loses out to HJ...Hj can provide any types/variety to any dirs...and churn out a HIT,which what is the big deal now... but again his most powerful onces again appear in Gautham's albums.... wat u guys think ?? |
|
|
|
12-07-2005, 08:00 AM
|
#3 |
|
|
sloshed...interesting things u have put up here... hmm..about Anniyan songs...ur asking what is ARR in Anniyan?? that is really funny dude,tell me what is NOT ARR in Anniyan...i wanna see that...
about classics...for me..the term CLASSIC is, when u can compose something outstanding,less of mass influence, more on quality & more on something unique.... in that, Duet def is in it.... what is so bad about Kulicha song that makes it falls out of the Classic list ??? i think its more on Folk+Modern knda song....unique i should say...we take a easy example man, has HJ composed anything like Duet Theme Music in his 3 years of beeing in the industry??? we count from 2001 - 2003...gimme a theme that has something beautiful like that....and im not talking about movies here...im talking about MUSIC..im not going to move on ARR's hindi projects...coz i really wanna compare & contrast ARR & HJ in the the correct time period and in the same field.... about the part u said...all a md needs now is a hit...HJ is doing fine...yes...agreed.... im not against with it, his songs fame is very very high...but to show ur diff & the 1 to be in the list with MSV-IR-ARR, u need to balance the hit & quality...remember ARR & IR never only gave a hit,but also quality at the same time... 
|
|
|
|
06-25-2006, 08:00 AM
|
#4 |
|
|
Yuvan's music is pretty good. I was surprised when I heard thee pidikka II in ARR's Guru song that goes Barso re sung by Shreya Ghosal. The starting music of Barso re reminds strongly of the thee pidikka number. Well done, Yuvan. The competition though is really between Yuvan and Harris, who were born in the same decade and within about four years of each other.
|
|
|
|
11-17-2006, 02:40 PM
|
#5 |
|
|
YSR's New Albums - Version 2006
YSR fans, please suggest any changes in the Intro post......any correction, addition, subtraction, i would be more than happy to do it......
|
|
|
|
11-17-2006, 11:50 PM
|
#6 |
|
|
Yuvan's music is pretty good. I was surprised when I heard thee pidikka II in ARR's Guru song that goes Barso re sung by Shreya Ghosal. The starting music of Barso re reminds strongly of the thee pidikka number. Well done, Yuvan. The competition though is really between Yuvan and Harris, who were born in the same decade and within about four years of each other.  then i wonder wat is Mayyera & Oragapilla - Sainikudu & Sillukum Silimisham - Chennai Kadhal is to u ???   do know when to use the term 'II' for a song !! 
|
|
|
|
11-20-2006, 04:17 PM
|
#7 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
11-23-2006, 02:28 AM
|
#8 |
|
|
YSR is aheadof ARR.
I have already mentioned about ARR's copied songs from YSR. Just remind for YSR critisizers. Kunnoru poochatti(Velai)>>>Dolna(Parasuram) Oru nenjam illaNalil(Dheena)>>>Smaiyai(Kandu kondein) Idu Kadala(TI)>>>New York(Sillunu Oru Kadal) YSR the award winner for RAM in Cyprus. Come out of the well before critisize others. |
|
|
|
11-23-2006, 03:21 AM
|
#9 |
|
|
YSR is aheadof ARR.  with the tittle of ur post it shows who is in the well & who is not...!!!  
|
|
|
|
11-23-2006, 04:10 AM
|
#10 |
|
|
Idu Kadala(TI)>>>New York(Sillunu Oru Kadal)  I also like YSR. His TI rocked our college days. With good lyrics and nice packaging, IDU KAADHALA song was cool. If you say that a particular song is a copy of some other song, when we listen to any one of the songs, we should get the REAL FEEL of the other song ! Prove this first 
|
|
|
|
11-23-2006, 05:24 AM
|
#11 |
|
|
"YSR is aheadof ARR."
Possible, since ARR composes for one or two movies each year. The comparison though should be between Harris and Yuvan. According to Behindwoods Harris is ahead of Yuvan and ARR is rated above Harris!! "I have already mentioned about ARR's copied songs from YSR. Just remind for YSR critisizers. Kunnoru poochatti(Velai)>>>Dolna(Parasuram) " Absolutely no resemblance. What are you thinking? "Oru nenjam illaNalil(Dheena)>>>Smaiyai(Kandu kondein)" Hmm. Kandu Kondein Kandu Kondein released in summer of 2000. Dheena released in 2001 according to Raaga. Moreover, it is usually the other way round, that Yuvan lifts subtly from ARR. Recent example is "Yedho mugame" from KaLvanin KAdhali, which is inspired from "Santhipoma" from E20U18. One can list many more. "Idu Kadala(TI)>>>New York(Sillunu Oru Kadal)" I am amazed at your skills! NOT. "YSR the award winner for RAM in Cyprus." This is a good one for Yuvan. He is a good MD and deserves to gain recognition. "Come out of the well before critisize others." Hmmm .... |
|
|
|
11-23-2006, 03:10 PM
|
#12 |
|
|
wow...music4eva....superb !!!
 and yes...KKKK was released in 2000,just after Alaipayuthey audio was released and Dheena if im not mistaken it got released b4 minnale no...and that was 2001.... didint thought of that seriously...wow!xml,what a logic machan.... didnt know ARR had a time machine to go into the year 2001 to 'steal' YSR's Dheena song....!!
|
|
|
|
11-23-2006, 05:16 PM
|
#13 |
|
|
Would be nice if we can avoid comparisions, YSR ***can be*** good, without even comparing him with ARR or HJ or any other MD
Just my 2 paisa
|
|
|
|
11-23-2006, 05:22 PM
|
#14 |
|
|
"Would be nice if we can avoid comparisions, YSR ***can be*** good, without even comparing him with ARR or HJ or any other MD "
Absolutely. I would say that Yuvan has indeed proved himself with several good albums in the last three or four years. His music in Arindhum Ariyamalum was top class, IMO. He has also composed catchy numbers in Kadhal Kondein, Dheena, Rishi, 7G Rainbow Colony, among several others. He is a good MD. |
|
|
|
11-25-2006, 05:48 PM
|
#15 |
|
|
According to Behindwoods Harris is ahead of Yuvan and ARR is rated above Harris!! Agreed, Harris has done better than all other MDs commercially this year. But looking at the number of albums and varieties delivered, Yuvan outscores everybody else. I think it is good to see both of them winning in tfm and keeping the rest out. You know what I mean? Vishnus' next outing after SARVAM planned with AJITH.Atlast some real big movies for YSR. |
|
|
|
11-26-2006, 12:02 AM
|
#16 |
|
|
seriously did YSR had any hits this year?? dun remember so... judge man, there were OTHER mds who had bigger hits than YSR this year! dun belive me ??
1.Unnai Kandene - Parijatham 2.Vaala meenaku - CP 3.Dailamore - Dhishoom there r more ... but this 3 would be enuf to show that OTHER mds did BETTER than YSR.... ohh...4got to mention...another Mega Hit of 2006 were Sillunu Oru Kadhal & Varalaaru songs.... vaiyiru eyirume..... ...fact'te pesurara...aiyo aiyo...ore thamasa iruke....!!!
|
|
|
|
11-26-2006, 05:42 AM
|
#17 |
|
|
"Yeah, as if their views reflect the true picture "
I just pointed out one source. You are free to point out to other sources having a different PoV. It will be good for a discussion, rather than a unilateral claim from you saying that "as if all their views ..." "Agreed, Harris has done better than all other MDs commercially this year. " Harris has done the best commercially in the last two to three years, I would say. Look at the formidable list which goes Kaaka Kaaka, Chellame, Ullam Ketkume, Anniyan, Ghajini, Vettayadu Velayadu. It is impressive. "But looking at the number of albums and varieties delivered, Yuvan outscores everybody else. " What do you mean variety? Looking at it any which way, Harris seems to shine all the way. People say lack of variety, nursery rhymish, hit because of good directors etc etc. But the bottom line is that his albums have been hugely popular, although I personally don't prefer most of his type of songs. Some of them, of course, I do like. "I think it is good to see both of them winning in tfm and keeping the rest out." No doubt the competition is between the two and no doubt that Harris is leading, IMO. Yuvan needs to come up with a cracker of an album or even two or three to neutralize Harris's influence on young people. "You know what I mean?" Please say explicitly. I don't want to read minds. You see what I mean? |
|
|
|
11-26-2006, 09:30 AM
|
#18 |
|
|
2006 hits for YSR
Pattiyal & Vallavan Yes Rahman is in his own league.He continuously makes new songs (as in tries to differentiate from his previous works) this is why he scores higher than HJ & YSR why behindwoods put HJ in front of YSR?becuz of his consistency as far as hits are concerned.Why are his songs hits?because of the directors he works with.yes one or two will actually sound good but the album is lifted once the movie is a hit.HJ music always has that deja vu feel to it.either from his bgm or from rahmans works.HJ is known for using his songs over and over and using the same bgm for more than one film. YSR hits the spot once inawhile as far as creativity is concerned (experimentation) yes he makes good music.but he stays within his shell most of the time.Yes he does good hip hop tamil mixing.but he doesnt move away from it when he tries to westernize songs.they all have the same feel.with two exceptions Lusu pennai and Eno Kangal.I want to see him tryin to experiment with that genre more like these songs. |
|
|
|
11-26-2006, 02:50 PM
|
#19 |
|
|
Slbperson,
When you say Rahman is on a different league.... I dont understand .... Actually I find Rahman struggling to catch up with the league he set it up in the furst place... I dont see different songs from him... where did you see any 'Different songs ' in varalaru? Anbe Aruyire? SOK? Apart from the enuf said 'two' songs from SOK.. that album is not 'mah precious' .. I dont think other than those two songs any other song is even played on TV ..let on reach the masses...and other than 'Innisai' ..I dont find a single hit song in Varalaru ?? .. less said about Ah AHH.. the better ...where is this talk of supersit songs and trying to differeniate/integrate business??? ahhh...wait a min.. these werent superhits becos the movies were flops... that tells me..even ARR's music needs the movie to be hits...sadly folks.!! One thing I agree though is Rahman is more talented than any of the current MD's around.. But that doesnt gurantee him superhits songs on the strength of it.. otherwise.. IR would be still on top.... Coming to HJ... so why are his songs hit?? Funny you should point 1)directors !!! ....Now why didnt we ever point fingers when MR and Shanker stuck to ARR ....giving him superhits one after the other.... working with directors isnt anybody's fault....and yes.. MD's would be more happy to have their songs hits after their movie is released .. then they know they have exactly given the song for the situations...classica case ...'ayaa veedu' from Mathukulu Mariyathai... didnt that song fit the place to the T.... I have already wrote enuf about the 'Variety thingy' in my previous posts.. i dont want to repeat any of it here... HJ is what ARR was some years back... his music is trendy and catchy instantly...youth now easily relate to him....simple... take an ordinary tune like 'nerupe ' or even 'rangola' ... pakcage it well.. add the special sounds ..an lo and behold.. we have a hit/... he is definitely getting more clever these days.... YSR to me hasnt proved himself... he is just a flash which occurs once in a while... where is the consistency YSR....??? I dont want to fall into blind IR worship whatsoever...let himprove himself by giving us a couple of AA... look at the junk he has given these days... 'KD...Vallavan...PV... and certainly I dont consider Vallavan as masterpiece.. if somebody does.. then so be it... seriously TFM need a 'followers'shakeup.. at one hand we have exciting talent such as ..Vijay antony .. joshua ...Prakash..charan... and on the other we see.. srikanth deva getting more chances than Vijay antony...phew!!! YSR needs to get out of his remix business.. and give us songs which will be in your hearts...and off course he has the talent for that!! |
|
|
|
11-26-2006, 03:36 PM
|
#20 |
|
|
sloshed,
Rahman is in a different league.Show me another person who tries to do a song like "Jillunnu oru Kadhal" "Machakari" "new york nagaram" show me another person who makes a song like "theeyil vizhundhu" show me another person who does a song like "yakkai thiri." etc etc and if you do i bet they only try it after rahman has proved that type of song can be a hit.No one dare to experiment like he does.If he wanted he can do what HJ does and that is stick to what is known to be a hit.But he is way passed that now and wants to do better things. Ah Aah - the title song,mayilrage, thazhuvadhu.what else do you want? As for HJ all he is doing is what Rahman did in the mid to late 90's.He is not doing anything different.that is why lots of people dont think much of him.He is just a high class deva.That is why his songs are hits because he is good at mimicry.He has nothing that distinguishes him.He just remakes rahmans classics.His songs aren't raves until after the movie is released EXCEPT Minnale The reason we didnt point at Rahman is the same reason we didnt point at YSR or any others.Their songs become hits even before the movie releases.Any Mani, Shankar, Selvaraghavan combo the songs are hits even before the release of the movie.Has nothing to do with picturization and the end result of the movie. ie: Boys & Pudhupettai. But when you look at HJ.He teamed up with Shankar.The songs were a washout with the masses until the picturization and the result of the movie. You even agreed that HJ is what rahman was some years back.And i mean that literally.HJ just mimicks. And i said YSR comes in flashes so i dont see why u made a long winded answer for that portion.Vallavan is better than any HJ album except for Minnale.Whose following?I think IR isnt all that.So stop assuming before you talk. |
|
|
| Reply to Thread New Thread |
«
Previous Thread
|
Next Thread
»
Linear Mode
| Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
|
|
