[plogypeskelry]

NATO forces are going to come out of thin air?

[Imagimifouxum]

The jerusalem question is complex, as both Israelis and Palestinians know, if not everyone else does. Its a good step toward peace, though.

[casinobonusfrees]

Originally posted by lord of the mark
The jerusalem question is complex No it's not. Israel is occupying a massive chunk of Jerusalem it shouldn't be - WTF is 'complex' about that!!?

In fact, according to the original United Nations Partition Plan for Palestine, Israel has no right whatsoever to be in control of any part of Jerusalem...

[nd90t3sf]

Well why don't you tell me where Israel has the legal right to be occupying any part of Jerusalem then - let alone the Eastern part, oh enlightened one...?

[Shootohoist]

When Palestinians to the man decided to engage/support in suicide bombings against civilians for 40 years. Forfeit.

They are lucky they are getting anything at all, time for the Pals to realize that and capitalize on the situation.

[SoftrermaBioniaSat]

[Raj_Copi_Jin]

The original partition plan was rejected by the arabs, and is legally a nullity.

The standing arab position is that the 1949 ceasefire lines, which had Israel in control of West Jerusalem, plus Mount Scopus, and the arabs (in fact Jordan) in control of East Jerusalem, including the Old City, should be the basis for a settlement. The standing Israeli position has been that the 1949 ceasefire lines are not legally binding.

The compromise everyone serious on both sides expects is that the 1949 lines will be the starting point, but that it will be adjusted - certain areas of great importance to Israel will be given to Israel, in return for territorial compensation in some form to the Palestinians. Right now what is being discussed is that a tunnel will be built on sovereign Israeli territory to connect the WB and Gaza, and that Israel will recieve territory in compensation.

It is widely understood that Israel will receive the histori Jewish Quarter of the Old City. They expect to also receive certain areas just east of the old city, of historic significance to Jews - the Kidron valley and the Mount of Olives. The Palestinians would receive all the rest of East Jerusalem, including the Christian, Muslim, and Armenian quarters of the Old City. To avoid having security checkpoints WITHIN the Old City, there would be a joint security forces, which would control checkpoints (at the historic city gates) between the OC and both East and West Jerusalem. I can see many prolems with that solution, but OTOH I dont see a better one that will be acceptable to both sides.

The Jews will get soveriegnt over the Western Wall, and the Pals over the adjoining Temple Mount/Haram al Sharif. Some protection will be needed regarding the subsoil of the mount, to prevent disturbance to archaelogical remains (Which may include the Jewish Temples)

Like I said, its complex.