[satthackacibe]

Assalamu alaykum

QUOTE=SASLAMS;797605]
its because they cant afford the expensive hajj. because we not indian & dont have the money The muallim fees for arrangements during the five days is 1400 saudi riyals. If there is a higher category for better accomodation we are ready to pay twice or even thrice the fee.

There are many Indians who live in expensive hotels across the boundary of haram paying thousands of riyals for accommodation. Haj is for one who can afford.

By the way! The real reason for ahnaf being stationed in muzdalifah is, for ahnaf, the stay in mina is "sunnah" and in other madhabs and for the salaafees it is obligatory.

May be we can close this discussion now.