[NADALA]

What about it?

He wasn't a Muslim. Im not reading his heart, im reading the historical evidence. He defined himself as a Christian, so why would I believe he was a Muslim?

Anyway, Monotheism is better than Polytheism (which trinitarian Christianity actually is), so thats good.

The question is not what he defined himself as, the question is the Quran ayah

"NO one is accountable till they recieve the message. "

Some ulema say that they get tested in afterlife, or that Allah knows what they would have inclined towards.

This is a very modern phenomenon, to think everyone automatically has FULL knowledge of the key aspects of Islam, for you would HAVE to read hearts to know this.

There were zero muslims around him. There was zero islamic literature, and no internet or mass media ? Tough to condemn a man under these circumstances.

We take for granted we were born into the religion.