[paypaltoegold1]

Brother Colonel ... did you happen to hear the video posted by Hanafi Fiqh Channel which has Pir Zulfiqar d.b. speak about this incident as though it was a blessing of it bieng saved.

I wish to know what is Deoband's stance on this ? Do they support the Green Dome or prefer the grave of the prophet s.a.w leveled.

If they prefer it leveled, then why do Pir Zulfiqar and Maulana Tariq Jameel d.b speak in support of its (Green Domes) existance ?

If they prefer the domb as is currently, then I need to know who saved it... Ashraf Ali Thanvi d.b or Maulana Shafi uthmani d.b or both [incase they are different incidents]

Brother, I have heard of the Bayan but haven’t listened to it and the issue of levelling the grave of Sayyidina Rasul-ullah is ridiculous and should be opposed because it has existed for hundreds and hundreds of years and many Ulamah have witnessed it and there has been NO MOVEMENT in the history of Islam to level it etc so if someone wants to do their personal ijtehaad they should be opposed.

There are possibly two cartegories of Ulamah on this:

1. Majority: Vast majority of Ulamah don't have an issue with this at all.
2. Minority: Some Ulamah may have an issue with this.

The minority should be stopped from implementing their opinion because it will cause hurt, grief and chaos for no reason. The Evidence for such an action is as follows:

Sayyidituna 'Aisha (RA) (the wife of the Prophet) narrated that Allah's Apostle said to her, "Do you know that when your people (Quraish) rebuilt the Ka'ba, they decreased it from its original foundation laid by Abraham?" I said, "O Allah's Apostle! Why don't you rebuild it on its original foundation laid by Abraham?" He replied, "Were it not for the fact that your people are close to the pre-lslamic Period of ignorance (i.e. they have recently become Muslims) I would have done so." The sub-narrator, 'Abdullah (bin 'Umar ) stated: 'Aisha 'must have heard this from Allah's Apostle for in my opinion Allah's Apostle had not placed his hand over the two corners of the Ka'ba opposite Al-Hijr only because the Ka'ba was not rebuilt on its original foundations laid by Abraham. [Bukhari]

I am just discussing the colour because to the best of my knowledge it wasn’t ALWAYS GREEN.