[MegaJIT]

The Mathnavi of Jalāl ad-Dīn Muḥammad Balkhī (RA) is always discussed online in various forms and discussion. I would like for people to honestly answer the question in this poll.

[SerycegeBunny]

can you add ' i have downloaded it and am about to read it'
?

[HwoRas1]

Marif e Mathanvi (on the Mathanvi of Hadrath Rumi rh) by Ml Hakeem Muhammad Akhtar db - its an explanation or a translation? Read most of it...

[MexicoCity]

Brother,

A person of your stature (whom Allah (SWT)) has blessed with a lot) shouldn’t think in this manner. Sure forums are a waste of time for many but it’s also an island (of safety and security) for many hundreds who come here (on SF) and look for inspiration and interaction at least online so we need to look at the bigger picture.

If SF gets shut down, would it make a difference for me and you? No!
Would it make a real and tangle difference for many others? ASOLUTELY.

For the sake of Ummah of Sayyidina Rasul-ullah you MUST banish these thoughts and continue to put your head down and SERVE and do so with distinction.

Hazrat you spoke what is in my heart. For people like me who have no proper access to shaykhs/ulema, neither pious company, surrounded by fitna (from where I come if a person prays five times a day he is considered pious), for people like me this forum is a blessing.

[MegaJIT]

Marif e Mathanvi (on the Mathanvi of Hadrath Rumi rh) by Ml Hakeem Muhammad Akhtar db - its an explanation or a translation? Read most of it...

Its a very brief collection of Masnavi and not even half.

[HwoRas1]

Its a very brief collection of Masnavi and not even half.

I'm capable of understanding only that...

[lidersontop]

never read it...i have heard little explanations of certain poems/stories in lectures by scholars

i have read other poems of mawlana rumi RA here and there...i don't really get a lot of them in their English translation and probably would never think of it like the ulemah explain it

[opdirorg]

I have clicked on option #1 as there was no other option near to my position. I read a portion of mathnavi in Persian during my early teen days. I have skimmed through the rest of mathnavi off and on.

[MegaJIT]

I have clicked on option #1 as there was no other option near to my position. I read a portion of mathnavi in Persian during my early teen days. I have skimmed through the rest of mathnavi off and on.

[CHEAPSOFTOEMONLINE]

I have clicked on option #1 as there was no other option near to my position. I read a portion of mathnavi in Persian during my early teen days. I have skimmed through the rest of mathnavi off and on.

same here. I've read but not full.

Good website:
http://ganjoor.net/

[giturbewan]

ive never read whole translation of mathnavi,just darse e mathnavi by shaikh hakeem akhtar db

[MegaJIT]

same here. I've read but not full.

Good website:
http://ganjoor.net/

http://ganjoor.net/moulavi/masnavi/

[rorsvierwelia]

The Mathnavi of Jalāl ad-Dīn Muḥammad Balkhī (RA) is always discussed online in various forms and discussion. I would like for people to honestly answer the question in this poll.

Have had honor to sit in Hazrat Mufti sahabs (db) dars of Mathnavi, masha'Allah it was amazing.

[MegaJIT]

Have had honor to sit in Hazrat Mufti sahabs (db) dars of Mathnavi, masha'Allah it was amazing.

Have you actually completed it cover to cover or just sat in a few Dars?

[rorsvierwelia]

Have you actually completed it cover to cover or just sat in a few Dars?

Hazrath (db) didnt do the dars cover to cover.

[MegaJIT]

Hazrath (db) didnt do the dars cover to cover.

Shaykh,

I have also never read the Mathnavi of Jalāl ad-Dīn Muḥammad Balkhī (RA) cover to cover but here is the 1st volume of Masnavi with Tafseer of Shaykh (Maulana) Ashraf Ali Thanwi (RA). Total is 24 volumes:

http://archive.org/stream/Kaleed-e-M...ge/n0/mode/1up


Here is the orginal Mathnavi of Jalāl ad-Dīn Muḥammad Balkhī (RA) which is in 6 volumes:

http://ganjoor.net/moulavi/masnavi/

[rorsvierwelia]

Kaleed e Mathnavi is a good book, maybe we can ask one of the khulafah from Hakeem Akhtar sahabs silsilah to do some tashreeh of some ashaar here so we can understand at some level.

[rorsvierwelia]

Shaykh,

I have also never read the Mathnavi of Jalāl ad-Dīn Muḥammad Balkhī (RA) cover to cover but here is the 1st volume of Masnavi with Tafseer of Shaykh (Maulana) Ashraf Ali Thanwi (RA). Total is 24 volumes:

http://archive.org/stream/Kaleed-e-M...ge/n0/mode/1up


Here is the orginal Mathnavi of Jalāl ad-Dīn Muḥammad Balkhī (RA) which is in 6 volumes:

http://ganjoor.net/moulavi/masnavi/

The Urdu in Kaleed e Mathnavi is very high level though its difficult to understand much of it.