[RicardoHun]

Assalamu alaikum.
I have a question, when we die it is narrated that our souls will be taken out of our body in the grave or painfully ripped out for a non believer.
What happens to those who are blown up, drowned in ocean etc..
They will not be in a grave or have a body?

[Catieliecutty]

Assalamu alaikum.
I have a question, when we die it is narrated that our souls will be taken out of our body in the grave or painfully ripped out for a non believer.
What happens to those who are blown up, drowned in ocean etc..
They will not be in a grave or have a body?

Your soul still leaves the body when you are blown up or drowned, even micro-seconds can be streached to seem like an eternity

[stoneeZef]

Assalamu alaikum.
I have a question, when we die it is narrated that our souls will be taken out of our body in the grave or painfully ripped out for a non believer.
What happens to those who are blown up, drowned in ocean etc..
They will not be in a grave or have a body?

bro.

Remember the hadith in which a person who was a very bad muslim, at the time of his death asked his children to burn his body and dispose it in different parts of the world. Then Allah Ta'ala resurrects him just like that and asks him why did that, he replied it was due to fear of Allah and Allah Ta'ala forgave him.

So we can understand there is no need of 'physical' grave or body for Allah Ta'ala to deal with a person. The punishment and reward in the grave is in the realm of UNSEEN. So even if a person were to keep a camera in the grave, he probably wouldn't see anything as these things are hidden from us.

Allahu Alam.

[RicardoHun]

Makes sense, I just couldn't understand it on my own?
Jazakallahu khair for your replies brothers.