[nemoforone]

Aslamo Alikum,

Dear All,

When someone denies God, then that person denies all good.

Because such a person says that actually good and evil does not exist, it is only our thinking that makes something good or evil. He becomes so blind that he could not differ good from evil or evil from good and he says that in the end, good and evil will be same because everyone will be dead and there is no one who will judge his deeds after his death.

Such a person denies Hereafter and Day of Judgment and loses all senses of good and evil.

It is evil to say that good and evil are same and just imagine, if we all deny God, then we will all lose the sense of good and evil and there will be no good left in us.

That's why God says,

Do you think, the person who does good deeds and the one who does bad deeds will end up same? What an evil opinion you make!

Conclusion:

Without God, man loses all senses of good and evil. This proves, there is no good but God.

[Elissetecausa]

Asalaam Ualaikum

It is interesting that you suggest this. However, I’d like to add upon this. When an atheist denies the existence of God, what he also denies is that objective moral goods do indeed exist. That is to say, when God commands that killing is wrong, it is wrong objectively. Whether or not as an individual you believe it is wrong, you know this is an objective truth. Now, take the instance that a God doesn’t exist, then surely objective moral goods cease to exist and as humans we simply rely on subjective models of good. So, for example, to say that the Holocaust was objectively wrong is to say that it was wrong even though the Nazis who carried it out thought that it was right, and it would still have been wrong even if the Nazis had won World War II and succeeded in exterminating or brainwashing everybody who disagreed with them so that everyone believed the Holocaust was right.

Now with that in mind we can conclude the following deductive argument.

1. If God does not exist, objective moral values and duties do not exist.

2. Objective moral values and duties do exist.

3. Therefore, God exists.

Now one may respond to this argument using a popular dilemma known as the Euthyphro Dilemma It basically goes like this: Is something good because God wills it? Or does God will something because it is good?

However this argument runs in to some issues it seems to fail because there is a third alternative namely, God wills something because he is good. God’s own nature is the standard of goodness all our commands and moral duties are by a just and loving God.

I just wanted to add a bit more to this, so people can understand it a little better. That it isn’t as vague as ‘without God, man loses all senses of Good’ but in fact he loses objective moral goods.

[nemoforone]

Jazak Allah Brother.

Thanks for elaboration.

After excluding God, there is no basis or foundation of any good left. Allah (swt) ko nikaal ker sachaai ki koi haqeeqat or banyad baqi nahi rahti.

God is basis of all good in this world. Subhan Allah.