[VYholden]

Yes, it is. I've edited my post to add the source.

I have Ma'ariful Qur'an.

[newpiknicker]

Yes, it is. I've edited my post to add the source.

I have Ma'ariful Qur'an.

it seems like everyone so far is advising for mariful quran. So what is the best copy to get?

[hasasnn2345tv]

Tafseer is a commentery, how is that strange?

The poll is strange because option 1 says that one should only read the tafseer, when the tafaseer themselves contain translations of the verses. Option 2 is also strange because it implies that commentaries may be faulty. Option 4 is also strange because it implies a person who does read a translation or a tafseer is not a proper Muslim.

[hasasnn2345tv]

why

Seeking knowledge is an obligation on every believing man and woman from cradle to grave. In view of this a person who has read the translation should naturally go for a tafseer to move onto the next stage of seeking knowledge. Hence the translation vs tafseer is a ingenuous question. Even the present title of the thread bags a counter question.

Q: Should a Muslim read a translation?
Q: Why not?

[newpiknicker]

The poll is strange because option 1 says that one should only read the tafseer, when the tafaseer themselves contain translations of the verses. Option 2 is also strange because it implies that commentaries may be faulty. Option 4 is also strange because it implies a person who does read a translation or a tafseer is not a proper Muslim.

option 1-A tafseer would be the explanation/commentry of the quran, so when u are reading the tafseer then the translation would be explained to u wheras if u read the translation by its own a lot of things to the layman would not make sense.
option2-No it does not imply that rather some people may be of the opinion that a person is able to read the translation and understand it by himself.

Overall i have created this thread because recently one of my reletives (who has very little knowledge of deen) asked for a translation. Now when i explained that u shouldnt read the translation by its own he got in to an argument. so i wanted to see all the arguments for and against. After seeing mufti sahebs video i am convinced that reading the tafseer is the best way to go.

[newpiknicker]

Seeking knowledge is an obligation on every believing man and woman from cradle to grave. In view of this a person who has read the translation should naturally go for a tafseer to move onto the next stage of seeking knowledge. Hence the translation vs tafseer is a ingenuous question. Even the present title of the thread bags a counter question.

Q: Should a Muslim read a translation?
Q: Why not?

This is what i am trying to find out.

[hasasnn2345tv]

option 1-A tafseer would be the explanation/commentry of the quran, so when u are reading the tafseer then the translation would be explained to u wheras if u read the translation by its own a lot of things to the layman would not make sense.
option2-No it does not imply that rather some people may be of the opinion that a person is able to read the translation and understand it by himself.

Overall i have created this thread because recently one of my reletives (who has very little knowledge of deen) asked for a translation. Now when i explained that u shouldnt read the translation by its own he got in to an argument. so i wanted to see all the arguments for and against. After seeing mufti sahebs video i am convinced that reading the tafseer is the best way to go.

You should give him the tafseer. The thing is, there are some ayaat in the Qur'an that require a context of history. There are some that refer to other ayaat of the Qur'an and if one hasn't read the translation thoroughly with understanding, he won't be able to connect the dots between related verses.

[newpiknicker]

Learning holy Quran online is an easy way for Muslims, new Muslims and

their kids to learn the holy Quran. . Alhamdu Lillah

Iqratadreesulquran.com.teach holy Quran 1 to 1 classes using the latest

software's, technologyand the latest Quran teaching methods . It's the

perfect way forlearning Religion and Islamic basic teachings in the

light of Al Quran,Sunnah and Hadith. Now students of any age in any

country can learn to read Quran at their own schedule and pace as low

as possible fee. Parents can now watch their children learning Holy

Quran in front of their eyes .
for free trial 923016822145
923344966931
or
h.salahudin@yahoo.com
visit.www.iqratdreeslquran.com

brother your link is not working. Can you check it out please? jazakallah