[rarpAcconavox]

Innalillah wa inna ilayhi rajioon

Asalamu alaykum akhi Abul Hasan,

What about his brother, Shaykh Shuayb al-Aranaut with whom I understand Shaykh Nuh has studied and who is apparently a Hanafi muhadith?

Anyay, regarding Sh. Abdul Qadir al-Arnaut - may Allah swt overlook his faults and enter him into His paradise.

[GypeFeeshyTes]

Inna lilahi wa inailahirajioum.

May allah subhanhuatala overlook his faults, forgive him, and enter him into paradise.

[jurnalkduo]

Innalillah wa inna ilayhi rajioon

Asalamu alaykum akhi Abul Hasan,

What about his brother, Shaykh Shuayb al-Aranaut with whom I understand Shaykh Nuh has studied and who is apparently a Hanafi muhadith?

Anyay, regarding Sh. Abdul Qadir al-Arnaut - may Allah swt overlook his faults and enter him into His paradise.

Wa alaikum salam

Akhi faqir, who said they are brothers? They are not. I have met Shaykh Shu'ayb, hafizahullah, and he is Hanafi and has no problems with Ashari's/Maturidi's. In fact, a few years ago a Bin Baz student attacked Shaykh Shu'ayb in a published book where they tried to show "Deviations" in Shaykh Shu'aybs Ta'liqat on Ahadith connected to Allah's Sifat!

Shaykh Shu'ayb is one of the greatest Hadith scholars of this time. His greatest achievement may be his editing of the Musnad of Imam Ahmad in 50 volumes! He told me that he was working on an abridgement of the Musnad. That was back in August 2002 in Amman.

Anyway, i do recall Shaykh Nuh's disapproval of Abdal Qadir back in 1995.

Wassalam

[rarpAcconavox]

Sorry Akhi abul Hasan, my mistake, my source must have been incorrect.

[jurnalkduo]

The sheikh of hadeeth, Sheikh Abdul Qadir Al Arnaoot has passed away in Damascus last night I believe. May Allah have mercy on him and reward him for his efforts.

Yes, he has passed away but he was the head of the Wahhabiyya in Damascus. He was once accused of tampering with the words of Imam al-Nawawi in his Kitab al Adhkar, but when he was asked directly by Shaykh Mahmud Saeed Mamduh if he had done this - al-Arna'ut replied by blaiming the Riyadh based Wahhabi printers for tampering with it instead! Arna'uts hand written reply is printed in the back of Shaykh Mahmud' book on Tawassul: Raf al-Minara (which refuted most of the contemporary Wahhabi lies on this issue) in nearly 400 pages.

Al-Arna'ut could not openly bring up the attacks that the likes of his fellow Albanian brought up against the real Sunni Way, namely, Nasirud-Din al Albani - since Abdal Qadir was surrounded by the Ulama of Sham who are mainly Madhhabi/Sunni/Sufi.

I think Abdal Qadir was more fair in his judgements on the gradings of Hadith than the likes of Nasir al Albani.



And Allahu a'lam.

[HagsPusia]

The sheikh of hadeeth, Sheikh Abdul Qadir Al Arnaoot has passed away in Damascus last night I believe. May Allah have mercy on him and reward him for his efforts.

[disappointment2]

Yes, he has passed away but he was the head of the Wahhabiyya in Damascus. He was once accused of tampering with the words of Imam al-Nawawi in his Kitab al Adhkar, but when he was asked directly by Shaykh Mahmud Saeed Mamduh if he had done this - al-Arna'ut replied by blaiming the Riyadh based Wahhabi printers for tampering with it instead! Arna'uts hand written reply is printed in the back of Shaykh Mahmud' book on Tawassul: Raf al-Minara (which refuted most of the contemporary Wahhabi lies on this issue) in nearly 400 pages.

Al-Arna'ut could not openly bring up the attacks that the likes of his fellow Albanian brought up against the real Sunni Way, namely, Nasirud-Din al Albani - since Abdal Qadir was surrounded by the Ulama of Sham who are mainly Madhhabi/Sunni/Sufi.

I think Abdal Qadir was more fair in his judgements on the gradings of Hadith than the likes of Nasir al Albani.



And Allahu a'lam.

Correct.
Let me clear up all the wrong rumors.
(Im his grandson)

He has no brothers whatsoever.
He is one of (maybe the best) the best hadith masters in the world.
The printing company did this on purpose to blame abdul qader Rahimahu Allah

Please remember this and clear these rumors.

[disappointment2]

Innalillah wa inna ilayhi rajioon

Asalamu alaykum akhi Abul Hasan,

What about his brother, Shaykh Shuayb al-Aranaut with whom I understand Shaykh Nuh has studied and who is apparently a Hanafi muhadith?

Anyay, regarding Sh. Abdul Qadir al-Arnaut - may Allah swt overlook his faults and enter him into His paradise.

Overlook his faults?
Abdul qader Rahimahu Allah was the best out of every scholar.
For he hasnt done a wrong in his life.

[Sleflanna]

For he hasnt done a wrong in his life.

Really? And you know that for sure?

[disappointment2]

Really? And you know that for sure?

Yes, i do

[Saduyre9de]

Yes, he has passed away but he was the head of the Wahhabiyya in Damascus. He was once accused of tampering with the words of Imam al-Nawawi in his Kitab al Adhkar, but when he was asked directly by Shaykh Mahmud Saeed Mamduh if he had done this - al-Arna'ut replied by blaiming the Riyadh based Wahhabi printers for tampering with it instead! Arna'uts hand written reply is printed in the back of Shaykh Mahmud' book on Tawassul: Raf al-Minara (which refuted most of the contemporary Wahhabi lies on this issue) in nearly 400 pages.

Interesting enough. I don't see the reason for doubting his statement. According to Shaykh Al-Arna'ut (rah) he had written his notes on the text which were removed by the publisher or whosoever. He mentioned that he had written his analysis on the narration of Al-Utbi which were removed. Mahmud Sa'eed asked the son of Shaykh Abdul Qaadir and he denied such distortion from his father side. All this is present in Rafa' Al-Manarah (73-75). Shaykh Abdul Qaadir had written his defense before it was inquired by Mahmud Sa'eed. He used to send it to whosoever inquired it from him.
See this:
http://saaid.net/Warathah/1/alarnaut.htm#_Toc70769592

[MiniBoy]

Interesting enough. I don't see the reason for doubting his statement. According to Shaykh Al-Arna'ut (rah) he had written his notes on the text which were removed by the publisher or whosoever. He mentioned that he had written his analysis on the narration of Al-Utbi which were removed. Mahmud Sa'eed asked the son of Shaykh Abdul Qaadir and he denied such distortion from his father side. All this is present in Rafa' Al-Manarah (73-75). Shaykh Abdul Qaadir had written his defense before it was inquired by Mahmud Sa'eed. He used to send it to whosoever inquired it from him.
See this:
http://saaid.net/Warathah/1/alarnaut.htm#_Toc70769592

how is Mahmood Saeed Mamduh doing these days ? Another Habib Hasan Ali Saqqaf in making ? how does that sound ? so Habib Hasan Ali Saqqaf head of which group and Mahmood Saeed Mamduh head of which group ? May be a little reminder about hadith of jabir on noor al-nabi rings a bell about tampering and publishing fabrications ?

Yes, he has passed away but he was the head of the Wahhabiyya in Damascus.

so, when the Ahbash / Habashis came to kill Abdal Qadir Arnaut, so does it mean Asharites wanted to assassinate wahhabis ?

muslims should be just and balanced. bigotry and tas'sub should be rejected.

[Corporal White]

Interesting enough. I don't see the reason for doubting his statement. According to Shaykh Al-Arna'ut (rah) he had written his notes on the text which were removed by the publisher or whosoever. He mentioned that he had written his analysis on the narration of Al-Utbi which were removed. Mahmud Sa'eed asked the son of Shaykh Abdul Qaadir and he denied such distortion from his father side. All this is present in Rafa' Al-Manarah (73-75). Shaykh Abdul Qaadir had written his defense before it was inquired by Mahmud Sa'eed. He used to send it to whosoever inquired it from him.
See this:
http://saaid.net/Warathah/1/alarnaut.htm#_Toc70769592

The brother you are replying to doesn't visit these forums anymore.

Furthermore, I don't think he was trying to cast doubt upon Shaikh Abdul Qadir's statement.

[AndyScouchek]

Innalillah wa inna ilayhi rajioon

Asalamu alaykum akhi Abul Hasan,

What about his brother, Shaykh Shuayb al-Aranaut with whom I understand Shaykh Nuh has studied and who is apparently a Hanafi muhadith?

Anyay, regarding Sh. Abdul Qadir al-Arnaut - may Allah swt overlook his faults and enter him into His paradise.

Asalam u Alaikum, Brother is Tafsir Ibn Kathir abridged by Sheikh Abdul Qadir al Arnaut reliable?