[Voitramma]

Untitled-Scanned-02.jpgUntitled-Scanned-03.jpgUntitled-Scanned-04.jpg

[Theorsell]

Interesting narrations, though I vaguely recall them being dealt with before.

Let me see if I can find the thread or article that did so.

[FinanseMikky]

There is a good and detailled refutation of Shaykh Nazim called The Esoteric Deviation in Islam by Umar Vadillo

http://www.4shared.com/office/AZ2dZr...-_esoteri.html

[Liabmeasez]

Untitled-Scanned-02.jpgUntitled-Scanned-03.jpgUntitled-Scanned-04.jpg

To reconcile with the famous narrations that Bro Fusus posted, maybe an inquiry should be made to the Ulamaa' about those narrations to see whether or not those females/slaves were either Rasulullah mahram or under the pubescent age.

[FUNALA]

Salaam alaikum,

I would like to know a few things about this article, and so should every Muslim before they jump to conclusions about another person who is not only a Muslims but also an accepted Shaikh by many other ulama.

- who is doing the interview?
- where was the interview done and what year?
- what language was the interview done in?
- who translated the interview if it was in another language?
- the Shaikh being allegedly interviewed language is not english, and what is written here does not match with how he actually speaks english. So if the interview was done in english, has the discourse been embelished or is it word for word (which seems dubious when compared to how the Shaikh actually speaks english).

Regardless of what maslak we follow we should never ever believe everything we hear or read, especially on the internet. We must check before saying anything, we are order to do so by Allah. If we are wrong we are slandering the person, and we will be held accountable. Also, if we do not know the authenticity of articles on the web we should not share them and spread them around. Rasulullah salallahu alaihi wa salim has that it is enough for a person to be called a liar in that he relates everything that he hears. So one may disagree with what is being said in the article, but before you insult or attribute it to the Shaikh, make sure that the Shaikh actually said these things. Man samata naja.

[pennadyFeet]

Salam 'Aleykum,

That first narration in the scans from Anas, is the one used by sheikh al-Qaradawi to permit the hand shaking of women only when necessary.

[beriarele]

There is a good and detailled refutation of Shaykh Nazim called The Esoteric Deviation in Islam by Umar Vadillo

http://www.4shared.com/office/AZ2dZr...-_esoteri.html

Indeed, Shaykh Nazim Is deviant Person. He is corrupt Person. Misguiding People on name of Spirituality.

[awagsFare]

What do Ulama Haq say about this shaikh? What is their opinion about him does anyone have any references? This will shed a lot of light on the situation.

[FUNALA]

Salaam alaikum,

I don't know who the ulama of haqq are, but Shaikh Muhammad Maliki al-Alawi, Shaikh Muhammad Yaqubi, the Habaib of Yemen, Shaikh Abd ar-Rahman ash-Shaguri, Shaikh Babikr Ahmad Babikr of Sudan, and various other ulama have praised him. I would like to see any non-salafi ulama who have said anything negative about him and if this criticism has been echoed by their peers.

[FUNALA]

I will grant Shaikh Abd al-Qadir as-Sufi of the Murabit have raised issues, I want to know if there are any ulama from outside of his circle and who are not salafi who have said anything negative about Shaikh Nazim, not about his mureeds, not about his khulafa, but about him as an individual. For example, it is not right to judge the elders of tabligh, may Allah bless them all, based on the actions of people that go in jamaat, 4 months workers, or shura members. They are free from the faults of anyone else, as is Shaikh Nazim free from the people who do what ever they like even thought they associate themselves with him.

[FUNALA]

Salaam alaikum,

to zubair:
Have you met him? Have you spent time with him? What questions have you asked him? How did you gain the ability to class him (or anyone) as such?

[18holesin]

Bismihee Ta'aala

Asalamualaikum.

I don't know much about Shaykh Nazim, so I won't say much. However, I would like to know what the Deobandi ulema say about him.

I saw a video of the Habaib meeting him. That was interesting.

Anyways I saw this video and am a little cautious when it comes to the Shaykh. Maybe all the females in the video are his mehrams Allahu A'alim.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jO1fI...eature=related

[awagsFare]

The shaikh meeting the pope:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ULgGMf1r3lo

[juliannamed]

If Nazim wrote the book 'Mercy Oceans,' and II, then he is a deviant misguiding others. Access the book on his website and read it for yourself.

[FUNALA]

Bismihee Ta'aala

Asalamualaikum.

I don't know much about Shaykh Nazim, so I won't say much. However, I would like to know what the Deobandi ulema say about him.

I saw a video of the Habaib meeting him. That was interesting.

Anyways I saw this video and am a little cautious when it comes to the Shaykh. Maybe all the females in the video are his mehrams Allahu A'alim.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jO1fI...eature=related

wa alaikum salaam,

What did the Shaikh do wrong here?

[FUNALA]

The shaikh meeting the pope:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ULgGMf1r3lo

What did the Shaikh do wrong here?

[FUNALA]

Salaam alaikum

I have not heard any modern day scholars in Europe or in Western Countries say the things that Shaikh Nazim said regarding jihad while he was in Europe, maybe only salafis.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6yIw780THmA
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rz881..._order&list=UL

[juliannamed]

wa alaikum salaam,

What did the Shaikh do wrong here?

Non-mahram women are kissing his hands and putting a hat on his head. And he's celebrating his birthday.

There is also a video where he curses and where he says that the angels only record good deeds for him now.

[FUNALA]

This is what Shaikh Nazim said in regards to the hijab and niqab bans in France and when the Azhar Shaikh made his thing about the niqab. The talk is about Islamic identity.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lAHZiFYrU00

[FUNALA]

Non-mahram women are kissing his hands and putting a hat on his head. And he's celebrating his birthday.

There is also a video where he curses and where he says that the angels only record good deeds for him now.

Celebrating birthday is fine, salafis dont like it. There are hadith that mention that when a believer gets to a certain age his sins are no longer recorded. As far as the women kissing his hand and putting a hat on his head, he is an old man and there are opinions that say when one reaches a certain age the limits are not as strict.