[zdoppiklonikaa]

are these two books same first one in urdu and other in english-
http://www.deoband.org/2010/12/gener...f-book-review/
and
http://whitethreadpress.com/publications/sufism.htm

[bonyrek]

are these two books same first one in urdu and other in english-
http://www.deoband.org/2010/12/gener...f-book-review/
and
http://whitethreadpress.com/publications/sufism.htm

No .. both are different.. the former is the sharah Bukhari shareef Mukhtasar By Allama Ibn Abi Hamza Maliki Al Andalusi also known as Bahjatun Nufoos.. reprinted again in pakistan after about 70 yrs.. a must have..

and the latter is the last chapter of Ila al Sunan by Hazrat Maulana Zafar Ahmed usmani sahab

wa assalam..