[wmcelesta]

it is said that peace be upon them from the day they were born to the day they die...does that mean they both didnt commit minor sin and mistakes?

[Loopyjr]

it is said that peace be upon them from the day they were born to the day they die...does that mean they both didnt commit minor sin and mistakes?

A prophet PBUH can't commit sins, because can't grip them PBUH into his trap.

[uniopaypamp]

All prophits are (MASSOM). They do not committ sin.

[StincPriene]

All prophits are (MASSOM). They do not committ sin.

Alhamdullilah this is our aqeeda

[Lhtfajba]

it is said in tafseer usmani (surah maryam) that hazrat yahya(as) did not even think of commit a sin nor did he ever did it.
subhan Allah!

[wmcelesta]

what about mistakes?
did they commit mistakes?
that was the question that no one has answered

[HexcewlyRette]

what about mistakes?
did they commit mistakes?
that was the question that no one has answered

Assalamoulaikoum

What you mean by mistakes? Errors of Judgement but which are not sins? Then such types of mistakes make have occurred. Even in the life of Rasooloollah (SAW) we have such events.An example would be when he preferred to give priority to a delegation which has come to see him rather than to a blind sahaba. Then surah Abasa was revealed to correct him (SAW) immediately. It was not a sin since for the Prophet (SAW) giving priority to the delegation was important as they have come to inquire about islam and his (SAW) mission is to spread islam.

But I will prefer not to use the term mistake but many people use it interchangeably with sins. And our aqeedah is that the Prophets (SAW) are protected against both major and minor sins

And Allah (SWT) knows best

Ayaz

[Lhtfajba]

i attest that the Prophets (AS) were masoom.'mistake' in ijtihad: yes, as they were human. sins: no

[uniopaypamp]

we told many times that all Prophets are MASOOM and they did not commit any mistakes. This is enough to understand about Prophets.

[alex_loudermilk]

Yahya (A.S) was Masoom also in the sense that apart from Isa (A.S), he was the only Prophet not to marry, he didn't have the desire for it. Isa (A.S) will marry when he comes back to earth. Wallahu a'alum.