[w3QHxwNb]

aaww
even the saudi astronomical society expects eid to be on wednesday.
http://arabnews.com/saudiarabia/article494126.ece

anyway, if no moon is sighted locally and no official sighting from nearby countries then my eid will be on wednesday (even though my local masjid follows saudi)

But astronomers, who differed on the start of the holy month of Ramadan based on astronomical calculations, are at it again. They are now debating whether Eid Al-Fitr, which marks the end of the fasting month, will fall on Tuesday or Wednesday. The controversy over the start of Ramadan is also driving the debate.

The Saudi Astronomical Society expects Ramadan to be 30 days this year and, if that is the case, it will end on Tuesday, Aug. 30, with the Eid falling on Wednesday, Aug. 31.

The society said the moon would not be sighted on the night of Monday, Ramadan 29 (Aug. 29) thus Eid would not be on Tuesday.

[rootoronpunty]

Its 7.30 at my place. So will know if its Eid tomorrow or not soon i guess.

[rootoronpunty]

No news about South India so far.


Its Eid tomorrow in Australia, just got a phone call.


So lets make the list:

Australia : Tuesday.


Edit: The mods made this thread a sticky, so look on the 'top' of General Forum

[Adfcvkdg]

But astronomers, who differed on the start of the holy month of Ramadan based on astronomical calculations, are at it again. They are now debating whether Eid Al-Fitr, which marks the end of the fasting month, will fall on Tuesday or Wednesday. The controversy over the start of Ramadan is also driving the debate.

The Saudi Astronomical Society expects Ramadan to be 30 days this year and, if that is the case, it will end on Tuesday, Aug. 30, with the Eid falling on Wednesday, Aug. 31.

The society said the moon would not be sighted on the night of Monday, Ramadan 29 (Aug. 29) thus Eid would not be on Tuesday.

yes, because there was virtually no possibility on sighting the moon in saudi at start of ramadhan on sunday 31st july . (saudi should have had their first fast on tuesday 2nd aug)
however because the saudis had started shaaban one day early, and 30 days of shaaban had been completed they had no choice but to start ramadhan one day early on night of sunday 31st july.

[eskimosik]

i dont think its possible for the moon to be sighted in saudi tonight, its still way too young... at least not with the naked eye!

let's wait and see what they declare after magrib salah regarding!

[Adfcvkdg]

No news about South India so far.


Its Eid tomorrow in Australia, just got a phone call.


So lets make the list:

Australia : Tuesday.


Edit: The mods made this thread a sticky, so look on the 'top' of General Forum

aaww
as far for those muslims in australia who do a local sighting they are on their 28th fast in australia (see moonsighting.com )because they had their first fast on tues 2nd aug.

so they won't be even attempting to sight the moon till tomorrow night (on tues) and someone has come up with a claim of sighting the moon when its totally impossible.

[eskimosik]

however because the saudis had started shaaban one day early, and 30 days of shaaban had been completed they had no choice but to start ramadhan one day early on night of sunday 31st july.

this makes sense, good explanation...so u mean... they have to do eid anyway on tuesday..

i.e.30 th.aug....cz. they already fast 30 days.

it is so confusing!

[Adfcvkdg]

this makes sense, good explanation...so u mean... they have to do eid anyway on tuesday..

i.e.30 th.aug....cz. they already fast 30 days.

it is so confusing!

salams sister
sorry to say but it seems you are confused.

i was talking about month of shaaban and because saudi had completed 30 days of shaaban they had to start ramadhan on night of sunday 31st july ie first fast on mon 1st aug.
whereas they should have really started on tues 2nd aug ie meaning first fast on tuesday.

as far as eid goes, its virtually impossible to have eid on tuesday in saudi. http://arabnews.com/saudiarabia/article494126.ece

[w3QHxwNb]

I really hope tomorrow is Eid

[Futfwrca]

Yes, if the testimoniance is reliable, why not?
We Hanafis don't have problem with global sighting, so it doesn't matter where the moon is sighted, on the condition that it's not astronomically/scientifically impossible to see it in that particular place and time..

Well according to the map, the new moon will be easily visible tonight in South-America, so even if Saudi claims to have seen the moon, we can follow the sightings in South America.

But I wonder if according to wifaqululama.co.uk this would be correct. Those who follow wifaq do not know who those "reliable testimonies" in South Africa are and how the news was verified, but still follow them.

Anyone from South-America here?

[eskimosik]

as far as eid goes, its virtually impossible to have eid on tuesday in saudi. http://

http://arabne...icle494126.ece

for this article and clarification!

[rootoronpunty]

aaww
as far for those muslims in australia who do a local sighting they are on their 28th fast in australia (see moonsighting.com )because they had their first fast on tues 2nd aug.

so they won't be even attempting to sight the moon till tomorrow night (on tues) and someone has come up with a claim of sighting the moon when its totally impossible.

bro.

Then i guess some people must not be following moon sighting there. They must be following saudi sighting or something. I dont know.


Nothing in South India yet. I guess will have to wake up for Suhr tomorrow.

[Adfcvkdg]

bro.

Then i guess some people must not be following moon sighting there. They must be following saudi sighting or something. I dont know.


Nothing in South India yet. I guess will have to wake up for Suhr tomorrow.

aaww brother,

yes looks as though there is more than one group.
if you go on moonsighting.com and then see the ramadhan sighting reports then you will see that some people in australia started according to a sighting in indonesia and some are reliant on their local sighting.
as for you brother in south india,there was not much chance of eid on tuesday anyway.
first naked eye sightings are expected from south america as explained on moonsighting.com
happy eid mubarak to you on wednesday.

[Bxbhtjnr]

We're going to be looking for the moon for Shawwal around maghrib time tonight, .

We're going by local/regional sighting.

[MrGunjMan_]

I am told 'Eid is tomorow in Saudi (Al-'arabiya news confirms it), Egypt, Malaysia and Indonesia; whereas in New Zealand it's on Wesnesday.

[disappointment2]

Suddenly 33 users are browsing this single thread. Thats a record i think. loool.

Man they are 119 right now...

No, 127...!

I mean, 131..

Well, ok...

[Adfcvkdg]

I am told 'Eid is tomorow in Saudi (Al-'arabiya news confirms it), Egypt, Malaysia and Indonesia; whereas in New Zealand it's on Wesnesday.

just checked al'arabiya and looks as though they have declared EID on tuesday in saudi.
ALLAH SWT KNOWS BEST.

[MrGunjMan_]

^^ Yes that's what I just said

[w3QHxwNb]

أكد مصدر مسؤول لـ"العربية.نت" رؤية هلال العيد في منطقة سدير وشقراء بالسعودية، ولم يصدر بيان رسمي عن مجلس القضاء الأعلى السعودي حتى الآن They've seen it here in Saudia but no official announcement yet!

Yipppeeeeee~~~~

[Adfcvkdg]

^^ Yes that's what I just said