[lXwVlTgO]

When somebody says that he will be there for 5 minute inshaAllah and he gets there after one hour, is he sinful considering if he does it intentionally.

[casinobonusese]

I don't know the answer. But Your question reminded me of this beautiful hadith:

Abdullah bin Ebil Hamsa reported: “Before he was blessed with prophethood I traded with the Messenger. I owed him some money and promised that if he waited I would bring him the money. I forgot my promise; when I remembered three days later I went to where I had spoken to Prophet Muhammad SWS and found him waiting in exactly the same place. Although he had waited for such a long time he did not reproach me, all he said was: ‘You have caused me some trouble, young man. I have been waiting for you for three days.’” (Abu Dawud)

I heard Shaykh Hamza Yusuf mention it once and thought i'd share.

[SeLvesTr]

Al-Hamdullilah
I always Al-Hamdullilah tell that to people whenever I speak about sabr.

[freddystone]

When somebody says that he will be there for 5 minute inshaAllah and he gets there after one hour, is he sinful considering if he does it intentionally.

yes.

[ovenco]

I don't believe so because is not an oath or a promise. I tend to use for things I would like to occur, such as, " my broken ibaadaat in this blessed month are accepted and my faults and mistakes are forgiven." Why would I say it for something that I do not wish to happen? is closer to a du'aa.

[Nifoziyfar]

According to the scholars of the Hanafi fiqh it is not binding as an oath so you would not be sinful

[lXwVlTgO]

According to the scholars of the Hanafi fiqh it is not binding as an oath so you would not be sinful

interesting

[JMLot]

Insha Allah means If Allah want's... any thing can happen it is one of the best word used to describe the ALLAH power

[gundas]

Why would I say it for something that I do not wish to happen? is closer to a du'aa.

It's the norm these days to say that and to use 'Wallahi' as a fashion.

May Allah guide these ignorants, Ameen.