Reply to Thread New Thread |
![]() |
#21 |
|
he is not Jewish. |
![]() |
![]() |
#22 |
|
In general I don't like the discussions about the Slavic or Polish anti-semitism as they may create the impression that it is the same phenomenon as exterminatory ideas of Germans.
It has not occured to me that Slavs are anti-Jewish either. The Slavs i have met appear the opposite. I have known Poles whose ancestors have suffered at the hands of Nazism. PROTEST |
![]() |
![]() |
#23 |
|
Most Europeans used to be anti-semitic but as French writer Bernanos - an anti-semite himself prior to WW2 - said "Hitler brought disgrace on anti-semitism". Anti-semitism used to be a strong Christian feeling with deep roots in European psyche : hatred for apatrids, for the nomadic ones, a dislike for cosmopolitism, suspicion towards the "Orient", taboo about money (in catholic countries) and above all the love for homogeneity and the community. My own family was rather anti-semitic and some family members still exhibit a silent hatred for the Jews, albeit under an old-fashioned "socialist" form : it's about denouncing economic collusion in the higher classes.
Such feelings are not socially acceptable these days in Western Europe. Two reasons IMO : WW2 really was a trauma for our elite and most Europeans don't know who the Jews are anymore, as they lack formal religious education. The main consequence of WW2 is that the Jewish population somehow has vanished from European minds. They don't exist anymore : the figure of the "Jew" is no more. I cannot speak for Eastern Europe but it's probable that pan-European anti-semitic feelings still can be moderately expressed because of political divergences after WW2 between the two Europes. But blaming Eastern Europeans and the Slavs for feelings shared throughout the Christian world would be ridiculous. |
![]() |
![]() |
#24 |
|
Every Slav I have ever talked to about this (and there have been a few, Russian, Ukrainians, Poles, Serbians) are all very very anti-Semitic, and almost seem proud of the elaborate ridiculous conspiracy theories they can come up with, as if it is a mark of intelligence to be able to do so (the more complex the better). Many of them (especially Russians) seem to think 'The Jews" are out to destroy "The Slavs, The Orthodox, etc". I find this interesting because before the 18th century, it seems the most tolerate place in Europe for Jews was Poland (although it was not that tolerant)...today Western Europe is pretty good for Jews (maybe not as good as the U.S., outside of the UK) but Eastern European is terrible. europeans have dealt for centuries and millenia with jews that's why they're so "antisemitic" they know how they operate you fucking retarded. slavs are all christians and more conservatory which means less prone to the media brainwash and propaganda in victimisating the jews, in contrast to the westerners ..... |
![]() |
![]() |
#25 |
|
Moscow would burn if Putin put a Jew in office. Anyway, the other extreme as embodied by American 'conservatism', where you have to worship the apartheid state of Israel, is almost just as bad. I'm not prepared to give Jews special treatment, whether negative or positive. If they have no desire to assimilate into their host country, they should leave, just like all other non-native minorities, and the world should hold Israel by the same standards it held South Africa a few decades earlier. |
![]() |
![]() |
#26 |
|
In general I don't like the discussions about the Slavic or Polish anti-semitism as they may create the impression that it is the same phenomenon as exterminatory ideas of Germans. only a retarded american wouldn't notice USA has 90 % jews in the government and finances . If that's not a conspiracy I don't know what it is. Most people who work in the financial industry are WASP. Please show me proof that most people who work in the banking/financial industry are Jewish. Also, most government officials are definitely not Jewish. Sure Jews are overrepresented, but most of them are not Jewish. Please name the Jews in Obama's cabinet. Please name the Jews who run Congress and the Senate. Right now in the Congress there are actually more powerful black chairs of committees than Jewish. ![]() If you can prove your rant, I will listen to it, however I think you are just talking shit. |
![]() |
![]() |
#27 |
|
And there had been polgrams in Poland before WWII by Poles(...) ---------- Post added 2010-09-25 at 19:15 ---------- Germans did not do that. The Kielce pogrom has been a difficult subject in Polish history for many years, and there is still confusion over whom to blame. While it is beyond doubt that a mob (consisting of some gentile inhabitants of Kielce including members of the communist militsiya police and army), carried out the pogrom, there has been considerable controversy over possible outside inspiration for the events. The hypothesis that the event was provoked, or inspired, by Soviet intelligence has been put forward, and a number of similar scenarios are offered. None has been proven true. Showing to the world that Poles are murdering the Jews was one of the main objective of the Soviet - and Zionists we could add - propaganda machine. |
![]() |
![]() |
#28 |
|
The extent in which Jews were money lenders is often exaggerated and not to mention, people forget that many Jews were at various times excluded from many professions. Many Jews were also physicians, lawyers, school teachers, dentists, etc. They were quite renowned to fill in career gaps. You cannot compare the Jews in Europe and the Middle East to unemployed immigrants seeking welfare cheques. Did I? Or perhaps you didn't read what I said correctly. Middle men minorities are seen as parasites by host populations. That doesn't mean I'm comparing them to "unemployed immigrants seeking welfare cheques." Did you actually read what I wrote? I believe part of the disliking was partially at a smaller scale envy related, but probably more so with regards to their exclusivity, which may have appeared as anti-social to many Europeans. I think its a shame people forget how Jews frequently fought wars with their host people and readily adopted many local customs. They did nothing of the sort until recently because they weren't allowed. By the way, it's very rare to find a Jew in the US armed forces. Compare the Ashkenazim from Germany today and the Sephardim from Bulgaria or Turkey and tell me they are not behaviourally any different to a Samaritan? IMO they are soo obviously Europeanised. Yiddish, Ladino and Yevanic are most certainly European languages linguistically. What is the point of this? It has not occured to me that Slavs are anti-Jewish either. The Slavs i have met appear the opposite. I have known Poles whose ancestors have suffered at the hands of Nazism. Personal experience means little. Slavic nations have a very long detailed history of rabid anti-Semitism. Every Euroepan nation that has had Jews living amongst them in large numbers has disliked Jews intensely. I'd say Germany in the 19th and early 20th century, with it's significant Jewish population, was somewhat different. |
![]() |
![]() |
#29 |
|
Give us examples, please.[COLOR="Silver"] ![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#30 |
|
Yes because we know Poland is so important to the entire world that an elaborate conspiracy is necessary to defame them. Examples of Polish pogroms of Jews in the prewar period, please. I am sure you are intelligent enough to google them. If you manage to perform this task we will compare them to German achievements. |
![]() |
![]() |
#31 |
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
#32 |
|
And it seems that for unknown reason Afroamericans are somehow also involved in this anti-Polish conspiracy. If Poland did bad stuff to Jews...so what? I mean it is bad, but so did the French, English, Italian, etc. Most interesting, perhaps, has been the Polish Catholic Church's reaction to the "discovery" that it was Polish citizens, not the German SS, that massacred 1600 Polish Jews in a small northeastern village during World War II. Far from the sympathetic or compassionate response one might expect from the Catholic hierarchy, the Church's response has been indifferent at best. snip On 5 March, Cardinal Jozef Glemp, the Polish Primate, stated on Warsaw's Catholic radio station that "death by immolation of (some of) the Jewish population, pushed into a barn by Poles, is incontestable." However, the Archbishop went on to say that he was opposed to the Polish nation accepting responsibility for the massacre. In yet another public relations disaster, Cardinal Glemp said he would not attend the 60th anniversary ceremony this July. "I don't want politicians to tell the Church how it should express its sorrow for crimes committed by some group of its believers. Nor should they propose an ideology to be expressed by the Church," the Cardinal said. That was the extent of the Church's expression of sympathy in regard to the Jedwabne pogrom. In a country that is 90 percent Catholic, Church leaders don't even bother to put a spin on their position. Ironically, Polish politicians, who would seem to have a great deal more to lose in the way of voter support, particularly among rural populations, have been more sympathetic. Polish President Aleksander Kwaśniewski, on 5 March, said that the massacre's 60th anniversary should be an occasion to ask "forgiveness" from the Jewish victims. Though a cynic might point out that this statement may have more to do with Poland's ongoing bid to join the European Economic Union than actual contrition, it was nonetheless a striking contrast's to the Cardinal's seemingly cold remarks. Relations between the local Church and Polish Jews reached a low point in 1935, when Cardinal Hlond, the Prelate of Poland, called for a boycott of Jewish businesses, saying, "There will be a Jewish problem as long as Jews remain (in Poland)." Cardinal Hlond's prophesy could not have been more right. Though few Jews remain in Poland today, relations between Poles and Jews continue to deteriorate, spurred in part by the property restitution legislation currently in Parliament. SNIP This brings us back to the Jedwabne pogrom. In May 2000, one such nominally Catholic publication, Nasza Polska, ran a story vigorously protesting the findings of Jan Tomasz Gross' book, Neighbors, which describes the massacre. With the English-language publication of the book, Nasza Polska has continued its attacks on Gross's findings. Poles inevitably blame the culture of Polish anti-Semitism on the ignorance of poorly educated and overly superstitious peasants. For instance, the Warsaw Voice quoted an old woman leaving one of Father Jankowski's masses: "'What the priest says is the real truth; this church is our Poland. We are ruled by Jews, so we have to fight them. And here is our weapon,' she said, pointing to her rosary." Meanwhile, many Poles, including those well-educated, continue to insist that Jews caused the Second World War, believing most Jews were Communist sympathizers who (paradoxically) grew rich by taking advantage of poor, hard-working peasants. But if Poland's rural populations were superstitious and ignorant, who was to blame for this? There is no question that the quality of education in Poland was poor, particularly in the rural eastern lands. Often the most educated and respected person in a rural area was the village priest. According to Gross, instead of preaching tolerance toward the local Jewish population, priests "evoked in their sermons an image of Jews as God-killers, particularly at Easter, making the season a perennial occasion for anti-Semitic violence." Moreover, Gross writes that days before the Jedwabne massacre, a likely pogrom was averted after the spiritual leader of the Jewish community visited the Jedwabne priest. This suggests that the priest did in fact have the power of life and death over the local Jewish population. So powerful was the priest's authority, Gross writes, that bishops and priests "in Poland often had to be appeased with gifts from the Jews. They were prepared to pay for protection, and for centuries the kehiles, the Jewish communal authorities, had maintained special funds designated for this purpose." http://www.ce-review.org/01/14/orlet14.html |
![]() |
![]() |
#33 |
|
my gf is from the Oswiecim area and I spend on average 2-3 months a years in the area. Never met more Holocaust Deniars and conspiracy jewish-hating theories than in those towns near Auswitz... although most of the people in that area are brainwashed pope-worshipers , gay haters and worst of all, very pesimists about themselves... its such a same, since they are generally such a nice bunch and have such a nice country... too many corruption I guess,capitalism hasn't happened to be what they expected after 40 years of communism
|
![]() |
![]() |
#34 |
|
Dude, the only thing I care about Poland is your women, and probably only a handful of them, Poland is not important enough for me to care about, let alone make up conspiracies. Trust me. If Poland did bad stuff to Jews...so what? I mean it is bad, but so did the French, English, Italian, etc. You were supposed to give pre-war examples when Poles where in charge on the territory of Poland not Germans or Soviets. Relations between the local Church and Polish Jews reached a low point in 1935, when Cardinal Hlond, the Prelate of Poland, called for a boycott of Jewish businesses, If this is the low point, I would think that the relations were cordial. |
![]() |
![]() |
#35 |
|
Being myself accustomed to the Slavic world (I speak russian fluently), I'm aware that anti-semitism is an integral part of Slavic culturalism.
Now you can say what you want but it is frankly honest and "sideful" anti-semitism never passionate like what we get in "the west" (where people hide behind "anti-zionism", in contrast slavs never do this kind of thing; they just say "I hate kikes" and get on with it; which I prefer). |
![]() |
![]() |
#36 |
|
No, they don't. Seriously, I'm not a big fan of the American South, but people keep acting as if nothing has changed since the 1960's. I'm always amazed at how people around the world think of the South in such caricatural terms. As far as I know most of them are mainstream conservatives nowadays, and I doubt you'd ever hear them say anything against Jews or Israel - quite the contrary. Using Stormfront.org as a source for what the majority of conservatives in the South believe? ![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#37 |
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
#38 |
|
So why have you created this thread devoted - party - also to Poland as a Slavic country. Think about it. It was a riot of peasants. Why start this thread? Simple. I have met nearly a dozen Slavic people in the last decade who have expressed to my face their dislike, ,distrust, or general hatred of Jews...always accompanied with some conspiracy theory. While I have met anti-Semitic people of other nationalities/ethncities, besides Arabs, I have never encountered so many people from a similar langauge family/geographic region express such clear hatred to my face concerning Jews. Keep in mind I know Germans, Swiss, Japanese, Chinese, South Koreans, Filipinos, Brits, Indian, French, and Danish people (or have met them and spent time around them) and only one of them, a Swiss guy told me he "didn't trust Jews...but he didn't mind them being around" that was about it... So yes, I was genuinely curious as to what Slavic people's shared issue is. Because I have this opinion (I know this might be shocking to you so, please brace yourself ) DOES NOT MEAN I've been brainwashed, work for, or even care about any Jewish interest or concern. It is an issue of curiosity. To be honest, I don't spend much time thinking about Jews, Poles, etc. The only Slavic people I think about on a weekly basis are Russians and Ukrainians and that is because I have two friends from both those places, one of them a good friend (who are also anti-Semitic ![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#39 |
|
|
![]() |
Reply to Thread New Thread |
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 5 (0 members and 5 guests) | |
|