[LottiFurmann]

suttrum vizhi sudare of " Ghajini" is thousand times better then Mayil irake

[Slonopotam845]

"anyway..........ir had done thousands of songs.............and u can mention only 10 songs.

but arr had done only hundreds of songs and i am giving the same number of copies....so who is better ....tell me"

So you accept that IR has copied and I did not accept ARR has lifted and that is the difference. Now you tell me.. who is better. THE PERSON WHO HAS COPIED OR THE ONE WHO HAS COMPOSED LIMITED AND NOT COPIED.

[Ifroham4]

dai piratabu....we will see..ok va????untill then....mind ur words ok va....i still stand with my opinion...Ghazhini looses & Ah Aah wins....wait & see!!!u dun have to be,AR hardcore fan to know that Mayilirage stands the best,Why??u dun even have to be ARR fan!! many my IR fans,y even my old folks said Mayilirage is a refreshing song after such noises so far this year!! and yes...including ghazini!! 8)

[Paul Bunyan]

Mayiliragai - Ah Aah

[TorryJens]

ok da... i come to ur level of talking...
mayil irake sounds like a usual hindi song...nothing new...when u listen to sutrum vizhi and especially to the lyrics u feel like ur in heaven.
The singers of mayil irake totally ruin the song...but in sutrum vizhi chose the best and a new combo...Bombay Jayashree and Sriram Parthasrathy

[radikal]

actualy,i felt bot the love songs from Totti Jeya & Gazhini a little lame, very boring beats & tuneless...from HJ which had good love duet was Enna Panthade & Mazhai Mazha - Uk.....these all r below average, but still the best is Mayiliragai...what a score!!!

[Drugmachine]

u cant be a ARR fan-pirathib........u see any ARR fan in DF they dunt go to personal attacks, they never call ppl. wiith names........even in hottest of ARR V/S IR arguements it is the IR fans who lose temper and call us with names but we never indulge in personal attacks(unless provoked) cos ARR's music is not just music but is philosophy- it teaches u many things.......

btw dinesh is not dumb

[MannoFr]

mayiliragai, it is obviously!!!!

[9mm_fan]

kokarako , there are enough Naradhars in TFM, so if u want to join please contact the admin and he would give u extra coaching to invoke ARR fans

[HedgeYourBets]

pirathib - u mean the nursery rhyme song - lol

[softy54534]

alias

I dont think this topic invoke any fight/war.

kokarako

Mayilirage should not be in the list. Its like comparing burce lee with super supparayan

[Lt_Apple]

"Saradhaa,

That is not theft! He has admitted openly that it was just a mere 'cover version' of his dad's original. He did not do it thinking that it will not be noticed"

openly admitted theft

i think there is no harm in YSR using his dad's tunes.........dont we use our dad's lic policy,savings a/c money,nsc certificate etc etc when we r under crisis......is someone criticising us for that????then y criticise YSR for rehashing IR's tunes????

[Fegasderty]

When YSR reassembles his father's song, it fails to impress (eg. Asai nooru vagai, Adiyae Manam).
When YSR reassembles song from other MDs, it is super hit (eg. Ennasai, Manmadha leelai in Theepidikka)

[S.T.D.]

Originally Posted by nilavupriyan Originally Posted by alias Yes give me the list and also mention how many songs IR copied (I am sorry for IR fans it is inspiration ) from others.

i shall give u the list of songs that arr copied as u ask....take it my friend


1)theme music of baba--------al capone by the untouchables - NOT A TRACE.... SO DONT EVeN GO THERE.

2)paarkathe paarkadhe(gentleman)----keelele by osibisa. YES MIGHT RESEMBLE IT.

3)telephone mani pol(indian)------combination of1)all that she wants from ace of the base and2)memphis stomp by dave gruisn in the farm - PURE CRAP. JJUST BECAUSE ARR USED THE SAME MUSIC LOOP AS ACE OF PURE, IT DOES MEAN IT IS COPY. JUST THE STARTING BASE WHICH HE USED THE LOOP. SO NONSENSE

4)anbe anbe(jeans)-------of these hope by peter gabriel - SAME THING... NOTHING DO WITH THE SONG.

5)thillana thillana(muthu)-------night bird by deep forest. THE HUMMING. THATS ALL. NO RESEMBLENCE TO THIS SONG.

6)jeans theme(madhumitha..)----famous album of micheal jackson ..will u be there. JESUS... STOP THIS CRAP.. NO WAY NEAR TO THAT SONG.

7)endrendrum punnagai(alaipayuthey)---cold hearted by paula abdul. TOTAL CRAP. YOU GOT TO SHARP YOUR EARS.

8)beat of pasion(taal)------race with devil on turkish highway by al de meola and steve vai. JUST BECAUSE HE USED SAME INSTRUMENT DOES NOT MEAN IT IS COPY.


hear them..................but hear them fully as in many songs the tune is stolen from the middle......

if u say these are all inspired then ysr is also inspired... NOW I KNOW U R SCARED TO GIVE THE LIST FOR IR. BUT HERE IS THE LIST FROM U COPIED.

1. Kanavu kaanum FROM KASME VAADE SONG FROM KALYANJI ANANDIJI
2. Theme from Mouna Raagam - FLASH DANCE THEME SONG
3. Chittu kuruvi (CHINNA VEEDU) - Antonin Dvorak's Symphony 9
4. Kan malargalin [Film: Thaippongal) - ABBA's Money money money
5. Darling darling darling [Film: Priya] - Boney M's number, Sunny
6. Entha poovilum vaasam [Film: Murattukkaalai] - Antonio Ruiz-Pipo's 'Cancione et Danza: 2. Danza'.
7. Ada veetukku veetukku [Film: Kizhakku Vaasal] - Mozart's 25th symphony, 1st movement
8. Poottukkal pottaalum [Film: Chatriyan] - 'My favorite things' from the all time classic Sound of Music!
9. Theeyani [Film: Nireekshana - The Sound of Music number 'My favorite things'!
10. Chittukku chella chittukku [Film: Nallavanukku Nallavan - Rimsky-Korsakov's 'The Tale Of The Kalendar Prince'
11. Kaadhal Vandhiruchu [Film: Kalyanaraman - 'Lady in Black' by the rock band Uriah Heep
12. Akkarai seemai azhaginiley [Film: Priya - British single 'Kites' by Simon Dupree and the Big Sound

wHEN FATHER ITSELF A BIG COPY CAT THEN CAN I SAY HOW CAN SON NOT GET AFFECTED. SO NILAVU STOP THAT CRAP. I AM NOT TRYING TO BLAME IR BUT BECAUSE OF U, I HAD TO LIST IT. the songs that have been made bold are heard by me too......they are not copy.but have a similar look.

that too mouna ragam theme is entirely different.

I HAVE A GREATER LIST ON ARR ....BUT I HAVE HEARD THE CORRECT COPIES AND SENT IT.NOT JUST COPIED EVERYTHING LIKE U

anyway..........ir had done thousands of songs.............and u can mention only 10 songs.

but arr had done only hundreds of songs and i am giving the same number of copies....so who is better ....tell me

[Slonopotam845]

Kanda Naal Mudhal is releasing tomorrow....

Thus, YSR comes with two faced gun.

[NeroASERCH]

Yes IR has given a certificate to YSR to openly copy his songs and put it in new format. Since IR is incompetent to compose these songs in latest format... Ada somma irupa.. it looks like YSR is running out of ideas thats why this new way of composing songs. Lifting his dad's BGM and music and composing it as songs.

[brraverishhh]

Its not wrong to point out copies as long as the person who points that out knows what he is talking. But in TFMDF, most of the time the so called copied songs dont even have a sandham resemblance leave alone tune or other aspects.In Rahman's list most songs range from fleeting resemblances to total non-resemblances.Same with Mouna raagam theme.

[Slonopotam845]

Yes give me the list and also mention how many songs IR copied (I am sorry for IR fans it is inspiration ) from others.

[Ifroham4]

alias

I dont think this topic invoke any fight/war.

kokarako

Mayilirage should not be in the list. Its like comparing burce lee with super supparayan

[Ifroham4]

Ean mayiliraga parthu ellarum A Ah nu alaruranga?