[luffyplayaz]

a must read post

Im just looking for answers please dont get offended




how can hadith be a trusted source of infromation, when it has past long time since the time of the sahaba and it was not promised gaurded like the quran?

doesn't the last aya in surat al Muzzammil mention a salat that is prayed on one third, two third or three third of the night,sence this is mentioned in the quran isnt' it faral/obligatory on us to pray that prayer, the aya mentions not just the prophet (saw) praying it,but others with him aswell?, if so how can it be only 5 obligatory prayers ?

In al Baqra 187 does it not say clearly, when fasting, to contingue fasting until nightfall ? not to maqrib salat!

The fear mentioned in the Quran is it not a physcal fear one feels?

Fear that grows by worshiping like the aya in al baqra ( 21) ?
The lies the hypocrites tel mentioned in albaqra vers 10.is it not about theire faith?

wich sura mentions the prophet (saw) raised up to the suba samawaat and recieved the faral/obligatory prayers?

In the begining of al baqra salaat is mentioned , as if thou it existed already how does the hadith explain this?

PICKTHAL: That is because Allah hath revealed the Scripture with the truth. Lo! those who find (a cause of) disagreement in the Scripture are in open schism
Isn't the aya really just saying: Those who disagree in the book are in open schism. (those who dont agree conserning the book are in great opposition against God.and his messenger)?
woudn't those in opposition include the sunni sect too?

[hhynmtrxcp]

aoa,

how can hadith be a trusted source of infromation, when it has past long time since the time of the sahaba and it was not promised gaurded like the quran?

actually wahi was of two types: the one which was recited (Qur'an) and one which was not (hadith). every word the Prophet (PBUH) spoke was from Allah (SWT).
both are protected. for we know exactly which ahadith are sahih, which are hasan, daeef and fabricated.

if someone doesnt believe in authentcity of ahadith they shouldnt believe in authenticity of QUr'an either as both came to us (i.e you and me) via the same medium.
please visit these links:
http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/show...ll=1#post30116
and
http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/show...ll=1#post30296

also visit http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/show...amp-A-Websites so you can contact scholars and clear your doubts.

these are nothing but doubts. in no time you will be fine in sha Allah.

[Cheaperisdeeper]

If your intention behind your thread is to spread the poison of Hadith deniers' ideology, then I have nothing to say.

But if you are a sincere truth seeker, then ask yourself:

- How can this Quran (which we have) be trusted as authentic? Because Quran was also revealed 1400 years ago.

- How can a non Arab learn to recite the Quran?

- How to perform all the worships which are commanded by Allaah ?

[ppfpooghn]

I don't know whether you know urdu or not,If you know urdu all the answers of your questions has given very nicely in TAFHEEM-UL-HADEETH.please read it .