[WomanBreast40356]

You shouldn't judge people by there religion but by there character.

Instead, Allah will judge us according to our religion firstly, and then the degrees that the Muslims will get in Paradise will secondarily depend by their character and so on.
And Allah told us to judge according to religion.

This doesn't mean to be unfair or promote generalization against kuffar; still, the first and foremost division is between mu'minin and kuffar.
Everything else is modernist liberal capitalist rubbish.

Just get along with everybody now and make the world a better place.

A "better place" is the one that Allah commands us to "build", according to the rules He gave us, and with His Din ruling supreme.